mojira.dev
MC-62197

Signs and chests display cracking animation incorrectly.

Cracking animation just got "fixed" for Chests (normal, trapped and Ender) and signs.

Although it's show (at least in my opinion) incorrectly.
I don't say it doesn't look good!

But with all other blocks in Minecraft the animation starts in the center of that block.
While thees blocks don't.

[A series of picture showing what I'm talking about down in attachments.]

Related issues

MC-62362 Breaking chests/signs bug MC-62406 Chest and Sign incorrect destroy image position MC-62738 Chest - Glitchey Breaking Animation MC-62920 Chest Breaking Texture Bug MC-63065 cracking (breaking) animation displays wrong on chests MC-63066 Signs have 2 breaking animations MC-63511 Breaking animation for Chest isn't mapped/positioned correctly MC-64030 Breaking texture does not render properly on chests MC-64420 the animation for breaking a chest doesn't start in the centre of the chest MC-64907 Weird Chest Block Cracking Texture MC-66808 Chest and Sign Breaking Animations MC-67528 Textures MC-67689 Chest Broken breaking animation MC-68481 The center of the particles for breaking a chest is wrong MC-69609 Chest breaking is off-set MC-70246 Double chest breaking animation on both sides of chest MC-71630 Breaking animation is off center on chests and signs MC-76270 When breaking a chest, the texture of the cracks is misplaced.

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media]
migrated

These blocks don't fit the typical block shape, so this is necessary to make the animation fit them.

migrated

How should I approach this then?
Is there a place I can make a post to tell someone to work on this and make a animation for these special blocks?

migrated

This was how Mojang chose to implement it, no one else can change it.

migrated

I noticed this when breaking double chests. Looking back at 1.7.10 release, there is no breaking animation. In the snapshots (confirmed in 14w30a and 14w32b) when you break half of a double chest, both halves have the breaking animation.

IMO if the animation doesn't "fit" the chests, that's a minor display bug, but when you break half of a double chest and both halves have the breaking animation, it appears as if you will break both halves.

migrated

Any reason as to why this was utterly reopened? I'm still agreeing with Anon that this is intentional. In fact, even Searge confirmed that it was intentional (MC-62362):

[Mojang] Searge (Michael Stoyke) made changes - 17/Jul/14 4:29 PM
Field Original Value New Value
Resolution Works As Intended [ 6 ]
Status Open [ 1 ] Resolved [ 5 ]

galaxy_2alex

Indeed he did, thanks.

migrated

No problem! Better late than never

migrated

I made a Survival World and I saw that on the Bonus Chest. 1.12.2/ Vanilla, Java 1.80_25 i copied and pasted from the first one i saw...

migrated

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 14w29b

Retrieved