mojira.dev
MC-65951

Armor stands fall through fences

When place on fence posts, armor stands will fall through to the top of the next block. If this block is another fence post and the post is removed it will again fall through to the top of the next block. I find this bug interesting and actually think it could be quite fun to build with. I have included images of the stand in all the manners that I could make it fall.

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media]
megascience

This happens with all items that spawn entities (Example: Spawn Eggs). The issue is that the selection area is in line with the visible surface of the fence, but the fence's collision is a half a block higher than that. As such, being inside the collision and not above it, it can just fall down.

migrated

I have noticed this behavior as well with stands on upside down slabs of all kinds. If you unload the chunk and come back, the armor stands glitch through to the blocks below the slab. Can anyone else confirm this please? I think it might be related to this bug. I was unable to track down a similar bug report.

michael

This can't be easily changed without changing how fences work

marcono1234

Should this report be reopened since this was fixed for spawn eggs (see MC-88096)?

migrated

I don't see why it shouldn't be reopened. If it's fixed for spawn eggs and placing an armor stand is very similar/ exactly the same as using a spawn egg, then there's no reason it should go unfixed for armor stands. It's been over 4 years since the issue was closed, and now the original reason for it being closed is no longer valid.

muzikbike

Use the following command to give yourself a spawn egg:

/give @s skeleton_spawn_egg{id:armor_stand}

If this is used instead of an armor stand, it will be spawned in an expected location, so a fix for the official item is feasible. However, with the fixing of MC-130242, this egg will no longer work.

This ticket should probably be reopened.

muzikbike

Affect 18w22b

migrated

Resolution: Won't Fix

muzikbike

Read the other comments.

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre1

migrated

This was already marked as "won't fix".

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre2

muzikbike

Still affects the full release of 1.13.1

muzikbike

Relates to MC-12730

migrated

As of 20w27a you can’t place the armor stand on top of fences, walls and fence gates anymore. MC-222121

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Low

Entities

Minecraft 14w32b, 1.15.2, 20w06a

20w07a

Retrieved