Chat Macro Error

i have found a fix using MCP, so it wont look exactly the same to the source code at mojang, but it should be similar enough to showcase what has been changed

in Minecraft.java, where keyboard events are handled, just before the handling of mouse events, change this:

Minecraft.java

}
				var8 = this.gameSettings.chatVisibility != 2;

				while (this.gameSettings.keyBindInventory.isPressed()) {
					this.displayGuiScreen(new GuiInventory(this.thePlayer));
				}

				while (this.gameSettings.keyBindDrop.isPressed()) {
					this.thePlayer.dropOneItem(GuiScreen.isCtrlKeyDown());
				}

				while (this.gameSettings.keyBindChat.isPressed() && var8) {
					this.displayGuiScreen(new GuiChat());
				}

				if (this.currentScreen == null && this.gameSettings.keyBindCommand.isPressed() && var8) {
					this.displayGuiScreen(new GuiChat("/"));
				}

to this

Minecraft.java

var8 = this.gameSettings.chatVisibility != 2;

				while (this.gameSettings.keyBindInventory.isPressed()) {
					this.displayGuiScreen(new GuiInventory(this.thePlayer));
				}

				while (this.gameSettings.keyBindDrop.isPressed()) {
					this.thePlayer.dropOneItem(GuiScreen.isCtrlKeyDown());
				}

				while (this.gameSettings.keyBindChat.isPressed() && var8) {
					GuiChat guiChat = new GuiChat();
					this.displayGuiScreen(guiChat);
					guiChat.handleInput();
				}

				if (this.currentScreen == null && this.gameSettings.keyBindCommand.isPressed() && var8) {
					GuiChat guiChat = new GuiChat("/");
					this.displayGuiScreen(guiChat);
					guiChat.handleInput();
				}
			}

it basicly tells the chatGui to handle input after it is created

also make sure to move that semi-colon from the top of the snippet to the bottom so that all of that code is included in the while(Keyboard.next()){} loop

I have tested this and it fixes the issue perfectly, however i do not understand what all of the code does perfectly, so i suggest not using this fix immediately and instead, see what changed and fix that

yes it is, updated with steps to reproduce

renamed to chat macro error

can someone comment, or do anything to this, it has been months since the last activity, and i would like this bug fixed in vanilla

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 1.7.2 / Launcher version 1.3.4 ? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

It is still an issue with the latest snapshot

Me not replying in a reasonable time is complete bullshit, this is 1 and a half years old, i have updated it several times due to being requested to, absolutely no action has been taken, it wont be fixed unless someone fixes it. I even fixed it myself some time ago with mcp. I haven't even actively played minecraft in over a year. If you keep treating issues like this then quite a few will never be resolved due to people getting annoyed with your bullshit, just fix the issue already. this isnt exactly a critical bug, but its still annoying, i almost gave up on it, and probably will next time.

Many parts of the game have gone through massive rewrites over the last few major revisions, and it's expected that many bugs will have been fixed as a result, without the developers having set out to specifically fix those bugs. Thus, we ask the people most familiar with the bug and how to reproduce it to check if it still exists when the game has been updated. There have been cases where we didn't quite understand the reproduction steps (or accurate ones weren't provided), tested for the bug, and believed it had been fixed when we could not reproduce it.

Since @unknown's rewrite of the chat system apparently didn't catch this, I'll bring it to his attention.

ok, sorry if i was a bit hostile, im just a bit annoyed with having to update this issue even when i dont play the game anymore

I will add this, the issue seems to be somewhat improved in recent versions, sometimes only loosing a few letters, and occasionally working properly, however it is clearly not completly fixed

Is this still an issue in the current Minecraft Snapshot 15w47a or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

Ticket resolved as incomplete, because no answer in a reasonable amount of time (1+ year), if it still happens, please update the ticket.