When using a fishing rod in the offhand slot, the bobber is spawned and immediately removed - the game only checks if you're holding a rod in your main hand.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 50
MC-83109
I was on a world using the off hand slot, and I put a fishing rod in it. When I switched to my food to eat it the rod did nothin.The problem however is: when I still had the rightclick held down, but my hunger bar was full, the rod began to spam
Resolved
MC-83495
Fishing Rods Don't Work In Off-Hand
Resolved
MC-83725
Can't use a fishing rod or bow in offhand slot
Resolved
MC-84010
Rod in offhand doesn't work
Resolved
MC-84080
Duel Wielding Fishing Rods
Resolved
MC-84351
Fishing rods with dual handling in the *Left hand* seem to be glitching
Resolved
MC-84379
Using a fishing rod in your offhand is not possible
Resolved
MC-84490
Fishing Rod doesnt work when in other hand
Resolved
MC-84530
i dont know if it's a bug when used, fishing rods in the off hand show a bobber for a second and then it disapears
Resolved
MC-84536
Fishing With Offhand
Resolved
MC-84910
Fishing rod not working in Off-Hand
Resolved
MC-85188
Fishing Rod Bug
Resolved
MC-86858
Fishing rod very glitchy
Resolved
MC-86919
Fishing Rod has glitchy behavior in offhand
Resolved
MC-86934
Fishing Rod in a off hand isn't working correctly
Resolved
MC-87298
Fishing Rod doesn't work in off-hand
Resolved
MC-87686
When fishing rod is cast, the bobber still appears pulled back in hand
Resolved
MC-87760
Graphical Bug
Resolved
MC-87933
fishing rod does not work in left hand
Resolved
MC-88111
Fishing Rod bobber from right, even when rod in left hand. Doesn't stay out
Resolved
MC-88648
fishing rod won't work in left hand
Resolved
MC-89088
Fishing Rod won't fire off of opposite hand
Resolved
MC-89668
Fishing rod in off hand
Resolved
MC-90336
Can´t use the fishing rod with the hand in OFF!
Resolved
MC-92176
The fishing rod will not work in the off hand
Resolved
MC-92281
Fishing Rods Don't look like you used them in off hand
Resolved
MC-92561
Can't Use Fishing Rod In Off Hand
Resolved
MC-93467
Bow & Fishing Rod not not moving when using your Offhand
Resolved
MC-93523
Fishing Rod Doesn't work while using it in offhand
Resolved
MC-94917
Fishing Rod doesn't work properly in offhand
Resolved
MC-96725
Offhand fishing lets you cast, then disapears.
Resolved
MC-97327
sometimes the fish rod when throwing the string will teleport back
Resolved
MC-97616
You can't use a fishing rod if you hold it with your off-hand.
Resolved
MC-97679
Fishing Rod in off hand doesnt work (with Video)
Resolved
MC-97867
Fishing rod not working off-hand
Resolved
MC-98284
Fishing rod bug
Resolved
MC-98402
Fishing Rod Not Casting in Off Hand/Visually Glitching
Resolved
MC-98852
C'ant fish with the off hand
Resolved
MC-98856
Fishing Rod
Resolved
MC-99105
Fishing Rod Bug with offhand
Resolved
MC-99328
Fishing Rod
Resolved
MC-100306
Fishing Rod OffHand
Resolved
MC-101908
Fishing rod in off-hand
Resolved
MC-102066
Offhanded Fishing Rods Do Not Work
Resolved
MC-103404
the fishing rod with the secondary hand does not work
Resolved
MC-104800
off-hand fishing rod line flies away from 0,0 (before dissapearing)
Resolved
MC-106888
fishing rods in the of hand
Resolved
MC-106990
Fishing rods don't work in off hand.
Resolved
MC-108005
Fishing rod can't be used on the left hand.
Resolved
MC-109406
Fishing using Off Hand
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 53
Confirmed.
Confirmed as well.
Seems fixed in the latest snapshot
Scratch that, could reproduce with having my lefthand being main.
Can confirm for 32a
Can confirm, very irritating when I want to get enough fish to dual wield and tame kitties.
Confirmed for 15w35b. It's not good to fish at night without a sword readied and able to fend off enemies wandering in from the riverbank.
Confirmed for 15w37a
Confirmed for
15w38b The line and the bobber are visible for less than a second, however the line also starts from the mainhand
Confirmed for 15w39b
Confirmed of 15w39c
Confirmed of 15w40a
Confirmed for 15w41b
Confirmed for 15w42a
Affects 15w43a
Confirmed for 15w44b
Confirmed for 15w47c
Confirmed for 15w50a
Confirmed for 16w03a
Confirmed for 16w04a
Another Confirmed for 16w04a
Confirmed for 16w05a
Confirmed for 16w05b
Confirmed for 16w06a
Confirmed for 16w07a
Confirmed for 16w07b
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre-Release 1
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre-Release 2
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre-Release 3
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre-Release 4
Confirmed for Minecraft Release 1.9
Please link to this comment in the description
The following is based on decompiled version of Minecraft 1.9 using MCP 9.24 beta. All method and class names are the names used in the decompiled version.
The reason why this happens is because the net.minecraft.entity.projectile.EntityFishHook.onUpdate() method only tests if the player is holding a fishing rod in his main hand.
public void onUpdate()
{
super.onUpdate();
if (this.worldObj.isRemote)
{
int i = ((Integer)this.getDataManager().get(field_184528_c)).intValue();
if (i > 0 && this.caughtEntity == null)
{
this.caughtEntity = this.worldObj.getEntityByID(i - 1);
}
}
else
{
// Replaced this
//ItemStack itemstack = this.angler.getHeldItemMainhand();
//
//if (this.angler.isDead || !this.angler.isEntityAlive() || itemstack == null || itemstack.getItem() != Items.fishing_rod || this.getDistanceSqToEntity(this.angler) > 1024.0D)
ItemStack itemStackMainhand = this.angler.getHeldItemMainhand();
ItemStack itemStackOffhand = this.angler.getHeldItemOffhand();
if (this.angler.isDead || !this.angler.isEntityAlive() || !(
(itemStackMainhand != null && itemStackMainhand.getItem() == Items.fishing_rod) ||
(itemStackOffhand != null && itemStackOffhand.getItem() == Items.fishing_rod))
|| this.getDistanceSqToEntity(this.angler) > 1024.0D)
{
this.setDead();
this.angler.fishEntity = null;
return;
}
}
//...
}There are however multiple other fixes required as well.
The net.minecraft.item.ItemFishingRod.ItemFishingRod().new IItemPropertyGetter() {...}.apply(ItemStack, World, EntityLivingBase) method needs to be changed to show a casted fishing rod for the offhand. The problem is that currently no hand parameter is provided so the complete method needs to be changed.
The net.minecraft.client.renderer.entity.RenderFish.doRender(EntityFishHook, double, double, double, float, float) method needs to be changed as well to draw the line from the correct hand.
Confirmed for 1.9.1 Pre-Release 1
Confirmed for 1.9.1-pre2
Confirmed for 1.9.1 Pre-Release 3
Confirmed for 1.9.1 Full Release
Confirmed for 1.9.2
Confirmed for 16w14a
Confirmed for 16w15a
Confirmed for 16w15b
Confirmed for 1.9.3 Pre-Release 1
Confirmed for 1.9.3 Pre-Release 2
Confirmed for 1.9.3 Pre-Release 3
Confirmed for 1.9.4
Confirmed for 16w21a and 16w21b
Confirmed for 1.10-pre1
This has been a huge issue for the longest time, Can someone please find a mod to assign this to?
@unknown We only assign tickets when asked to do so by mojang, in any other circumstances we should not mess with the assignment field.
Confirmed for 1.10-pre2
Confirmed for 1.10
Confirmed in 1.10.2
There's also a visual bug where the line goes away from the player about 15 blocks or so and also another line to the player where the bobber appears. The line always goes to the east. Just reported this bug.
Agnes Larsson
Duplicate ofMC-83109