Code analysis by @unknown can be found in this comment.
Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-93753
fence sound
MC-93769
Fences placed on other fences don't have a sound, or subtitle.
MC-94140
placing blocks on fences
MC-94276
Silent Fenceposts
MC-94344
Problem whit fence's sound!!
MC-94391
One sound not playing
MC-94714
Blocks placed on fences produce no sound.
MC-94976
Sound Missing with fence
MC-95386
Fences don't make their usual placing sounds
MC-95433
Torches doesn't make a sound when put on a fence
MC-96288
no sound when place fence to another
MC-96490
Placing fences next to other fences that have at least 1 block of air between the ground makes no sound.
MC-96616
Put a block on a fence no play sounds
MC-96628
Place a fence on a other fence don't give a place sound
MC-96741
no sound when putting fences
MC-96823
placing a fence on a fence don't give a place sound
MC-97193
Putting blocks in top of fences doesn't make any sound.
MC-97381
Placing a wooden fence in top of another wooden fence is missing a sound.
MC-97486
sound bug
MC-97561
No sound when placing Blocks on fences
MC-97604
When placing blocks on fences, no sound is played.
MC-97686
Putting fence on top of another fence doesn't play block sound
MC-97729
Fences don't make placing noises when placed on each other
MC-97731
Torches don't make placing noise when placed on a fence
MC-97994
Fences sound bug
MC-98026
No sound when placing a block on a fence
MC-98065
Fences sound bug
MC-98385
If I place a block attached to a fence, it isn't playing the place sound!
MC-98492
No placing noise for anything on fence post
MC-98773
When placing a block on a fence block the placement will make no sound.
MC-98818
Missing fence Sounds
MC-98904
Fence sound bug and bow bug
MC-99026
Sound errors when placing blocks onto fences
MC-99124
Minecart name screwed up?
MC-99207
No sound plays when torch is placed on top of wooden fence
MC-99381
No sound for torch
MC-99437
If you place a block on a fence, it doesn't play a sound.
MC-100299
Fences no sound!
MC-100657
Placing blocks on fences
MC-101564
Torches placed on wooden fences play no sound
MC-101787
when placing fences in the ai it does not produce a sound
MC-101848
Fences Sounds are bugged
MC-101878
wrong sound of glass block and no sound of fence
MC-102003
Fence Placing Sound Bug
MC-102794
sound bug
MC-102886
Stairs don't make a sound when placed on stairs
MC-102919
Fence
MC-103037
No block place sound when placing blocks on fences
MC-103118
Placing a fence/wall on top of another fence/wall will not play the place sound.
MC-103361
There are no sounds for placing any block on fence posts
MC-103537
Sound bug with fences
MC-104573
Sound missing when placing fence over fence.
MC-104656
When placing Torch on a Fence there is no sound
MC-105316
No Blockplacing sound played by blocks placed on, under or next to fences
MC-105497
No sound for placing fence on fence
MC-105547
Fence Sound Bug
MC-105901
When you place a fence on top of another fence, the audio doesn't play.
MC-105985
Placing Fence on a fence doesn't make a noise
MC-106371
Placing blocks on top of fences have no noise
MC-106480
dreagon head bugs
MC-106608
Blocks on fences don't make sounds
MC-106830
Block Placement sound does not work on fences unless crouching.
MC-106838
No sound when a fence is placed on a fence
MC-107351
Sound Not Working
MC-108927
Blocks placed on fences do not make a sound
MC-108947
No noise when you place a block on top of a fence post
MC-108971
No sound while placing a block on a wooden fenced
MC-109159
Noise of torch being placed on fence posts doesent play
MC-109337
Fence makes no sound upon placement
MC-109828
Armor Equipping Sound not played when looking at a fence
MC-109830
Torches don't make placing sound on Fences, unless Shift is pressed
MC-109930
No sound or subtitle made when placing blocks on fences
Attachments
Comments
migrated
[Mod]Les3awe
Can confirm.
[Mod]Les3awe
Confirmed for 15w50a
migrated
Still an issue in 15w51b
migrated
still seems to be an issue in 16w02a
wobst.michael
Issue confirmed for 16w02a.
wobst.michael
Issue in 16w03a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w04a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w05a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w05b
migrated
Still an issue in 16w06a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w07a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w07b
migrated
Still an issue in 1.9-pre1
migrated
Still an issue in 1.9 Pre-Release 2
elrichmc
Pressing Shift you can hear the sound, without pressing it the issue stills there. Tested on 1.9 Pre-Release 1
migrated
Confirmed for Pre-Release 2
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre-Release 3
migrated
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre3
migrated
please help Mojang out by not posting a comment that's the same a one before it, they're swamped enough as it is.
elrichmc
Confirmed for 1.9 Pre-Release 4
migrated
Confirmed for 1.9 ..
migrated
More detail in 1.9:
If you shift-click while placing a block on the fence, it makes the proper placement sound. This seems to be an interaction between the "attempting to 'use' item/tool on the fencepost" and "attempting to place a block on the fencepost" functions, as seen when you try to eat food while having the cursor over a fencepost.
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9.1 Pre-Release 1
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9.1 Pre-Release 2
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9.1 Pre-Release 3
migrated
bug is still here - 1.9.2
marcono1234
Please link to this comment in the description
The following is based on decompiled version of Minecraft 1.9 using MCP 9.24 beta. All method and class names are the names used in the decompiled version.
The reason why this happens is because the method net.minecraft.block.BlockFence.onBlockActivated(World, BlockPos, IBlockState, EntityPlayer, EnumHand, ItemStack, EnumFacing, float, float, float) returns for the client always true, this means the client always acts as if it interacted with the fence.
In general the client places a block which creates the sound and sends a packet to the server. The server creates the sound then for all other players because it assumes the client placing the block acted the same way the server did and already played the sound.
The problem is that the client did not play the sound, but the server does not know that.
This could be solved by sending the server also what the client thought would happen. In this case interacting with the fence instead of placing a block. Then the server could send the sound to this client as well if the action differs from the one the server did.
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w14a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w15a
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w15b
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9.3 Pre-Release 1
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9.3 Pre-Release 2
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.9.3 Pre-Release 3
violine1101
Still in 1.9.4
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 16w20a
violine1101
Still in 16w21a and 16w21b
migrated
Still in 1.10 pre1
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.10-pre2
migrated
confirmed for 1.10
migrated
Confirmed for 1.10 : All Versions
Still broken since 1.9. Fix in plan?
It does play a sound when shift-right click.
[Mod] Neko
Confirmed for 1.10.2
pokechu22
Underlying cause is MC-21433 (which is WIA :/)
marcono1234
That is not quite the problem here as the block is placed. The problem is that the client always asumes that it interacted with the fence whereas the server does not behave like this and places the block.
pokechu22
marcono1234
Sorry, yes you are right. I thought they acted the same way iron doors or trapdoors act.
Mods please do not close this report as a duplicate because then we have an unnecessary discussion about whether or not it is WAI and like @unknown said it is definitely not.
I would suggest fixing it by having client and server call the method net.minecraft.item.ItemLead.attachToFence(EntityPlayer, World, BlockPos) but change this method to only create the LeashKnot and leash the entity server-side.
Note: The method net.minecraft.item.ItemLead.onItemUse(ItemStack, EntityPlayer, World, BlockPos, EnumHand, EnumFacing, float, float, float) contains kind of dead code because if the player successfully interacts with a block it will not use the item. If the player fails right clicking while holding a leash, this method will fail as well.
violine1101
Still in 16w38a.
Erik Broes