mojira.dev
MCL-2991

Old versions use new sounds

When playing older versions of Minecraft (Beta 1.7.3 and below), all of the new Minecraft sounds are used instead of the older ones.

Linked issues

MC-28248 No sound in minecraft version under beta 1.3 Resolved MC-28450 Old version use modern sounds in some cases Resolved MC-29218 sounds in old version beta 1.7.3 not the old sounds Resolved MC-108186 Old beta sounds are being replaced by the new sounds. And spawn rate of mobs have decreased. Resolved MC-123058 Minecraft alpha and beta versions using new sound effects Resolved

Comments 10

Re-opening, as this ticket was incorrectly resolved as invalid.

Cannot reproduce anymore with the newer launcher versions (tried Alpha 1.2.0_02 and Beta 1.7.3, both have old sounds). Anyone else still having this issue?

I can only reproduce with door sounds

@unknown, in which version?

only with door sounds no other sounds for example cow sounds were the old versions sounds

I used the latest launcher

Just gonna put my support into here, and to also elaborate on the problem just a bit more. All versions from release 1.5.2 back to alpha 1.1.2_01 use the same sounds, which is inaccurate. Between beta 1.8 and release 1.0 there was a sound update changing several sounds like the arrow firing sound and the door sounds. Some more info can be found on the wiki here. https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Beta_Sound_Update A simple fix would just be to give either beta 1.7.3 or beta 1.8 and before a custom sound JSON to give them the original sounds from before that sound update.

After some basic testing, the door sound on 1.2.0_02 is now the old one.

As for the the point Redspyro99 made, that does indeed still apply, but it is qute a niche issue. The ticket however will remain open for that.

I think it would make sense to create a separate report for this since that might be a separate issue and this report for example mentions "Beta 1.7.3 and below" which is according to that comment not affected.

@@unknown could you please create a separate report for this?

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

sounds

Retrieved