mojira.dev
MCPE-11477

Levers, Signs, Item Frames, Ladders, Paintings, Torches, and Redstone torches drop if connected to a block in a different chunk

What I expected to happen. When you place a Redstone torch so it connects to the side of a block, it will stay connected even if I leave the chunk the blocks is in but keep the chunk the torch is in.

What happens is the redstone torch drops itself as an item as If i broke the block it was connected to.

To reproduce: Find a chunk boundry and place a block that a redstone torch can be placed on the side of on 1 side ofthe boundry, place the torch on the other side of the boundary so it connect to the other block but is in a different chunk. Fly away some distance so that both chunks become unloaded. Walk back to the place where you had the torch. You will see that the torch has dropped itself as an Item.
Update by @unknown:

Also affects:

  • Lever

  • Sign

  • Torches

Update by @unknown:
There are steps to reproduce this in MCPE-17271.

Moderator note by @unknown:
Please limit comments to only new information regarding the issue.

Linked issues

MCPE-12014 Redstone Torches keep Breaking Resolved MCPE-13457 Breaking Redstone Torches Resolved MCPE-13520 Redstone Torches keeps disappearing Resolved MCPE-14092 redstone torch Resolved MCPE-14469 Returning From Nether Causes Random Signs to Break Resolved

Attachments

Comments 39

@unknown confirmed this still a problem in build 5.

Dr.Awesome4333

Confirmed on 0.13.0 too

confirmed for 0.13.1

I've seen this several times in 0.14.0. Not sure about 0.14.1.

29 more comments

This bug occurs with cocoa pods and beds in 1.14.30. However, I cannot reproduce this bug with any of the blocks listed in the title, so I think the fix in 1.2.0.11 was successful. I have created a new ticket for cocoa pods, MCPE-67479.

Just had this happen today. I've loaded this world a dozen times and today when I loaded in, all the paintings in the room where I had logged out in were floating on the ground. It was just the one room and it DID occur along chunk borders. I'm guessing the chunk with the paintings loaded in first without the wall in the next chunk attached to it? 

Just had it happen again. Interestingly enough it didn't happen when I loaded in. I checked to make sure everything was intact, then told my friend to go ahead and join. When SHE logged in I saw everything pop off. Everything was fine for me when I loaded in but a friend joining caused the issue. This was probably the case the first time as well but I wasn't paying attention for it. She noticed it that time as well. She also loads into the same room as me. Incase I didn't mention, this is a local world.

Can we please have this ticket reopened? It's clearly not fixed. 

Chris: the issue you are describing is tracked at MCPE-142303.

Thanks Helmet! I'll go check it out. 

Dr.Awesome4333

(Unassigned)

74547

Confirmed

Tablet - Android - Samsung Galaxy Tab 3

Android 5.0.1

chunk-border, chunk-loading, item_frame, ladder, lever, painting, redstone_torch, sign, torch

0.13.0 Beta 1, 0.13.0 Beta 5, 0.13.0, 0.14.3, 0.15.0, ..., 1.1.2.50, 1.1.3.52, 1.1.4.51, 1.2.0.2, 1.5.1.2

1.2.0.11

Retrieved