mojira.dev
MCPE-44320

Collecting fishes with a bucket places them immediately after

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Spawn any type of fish in a 1x1 hole;

  2. Point at it and use a bucket/bucket of water;

Expected results:
The fish is collected, and can be used later in another place.

Observed results:
The fish is collected and placed immediately after.

Workaround:
Collect the fish in a way that you won't be able to reach another block after doing so.

Tested platforms:
Windows 10: Affected
Mobile (Android): Affected, in a different way (You begin to mine the block behind).

Linked issues

BDS-10388 Can't put fish in a bucket MCPE-68497 Fish are very difficult to catch in a bucket MCPE-91468 Bucket can’t pick up fish MCPE-123269 Axolotl and fish sometimes do not go into the bucket MCPE-126141 I can't pick up axolotls and fish with buckets MCPE-126361 problems with axolotls and buckets MCPE-130834 Cannot pick up axolotl or fish in bucket MCPE-130877 Picking up axolotls in buckets is kind of twitchy MCPE-130944 Cant pick up an axolotl with a bucket. Automatically put its back in water MCPE-131083 Scooping up and Axolotl with a bucket immediately releases the Axolotl MCPE-131129 Axolots are hard to pick up with bucket and duplicates water MCPE-131142 I can't pick up an axolotl MCPE-131157 Axolotl can’t be caught in a bucket MCPE-131298 I cannot pick up my axolotl in a bucket. MCPE-131340 Unable to pick up axolotls with a bucket MCPE-131396 Unable to pick up axolotl MCPE-132136 You can't pick up an axolotl in a bucket it instantly throws him away MCPE-132741 new update axolotl issue MCPE-132750 Can't use bucket to pick up any fish in water MCPE-132804 Axolotl Cannot be Picked up by Bucket MCPE-133060 Water duplication glitch while trying to bucket an axolotl MCPE-133074 Axolotl comes back out of bucket after collecting it MCPE-133393 When ever I try to pick up an axolotl it places the axolotl down and I have to keep trying until it finally let's me pick the axolotl up after a few trys MCPE-133659 Cannot pick up axlotol MCPE-133813 Cannot put mob on water bucket. MCPE-133956 Axolotls, empty buckets, and water MCPE-134013 When Picking up a Axolotl in a bucket in light water sometimes it would just give you a full water bucket causing infinite water MCPE-134348 Can't pick up axolotl in bucket MCPE-135429 Axolotls hard to pick up MCPE-135769 Not being able to pick up axolotls or fish MCPE-135900 Unable to pick up axolotls with a bucket MCPE-136519 axolotls come out of the bucket by themselves MCPE-136568 Unable to catch axolotl in bucket. MCPE-137116 The axolotl will not come in the bucket when I click on it using a PS4 controller. MCPE-137302 Cant get axolotl with water bucket MCPE-137659 It won't put axolotls in buckets MCPE-137851 Catching a cod/salmon/pufferfish/tropical fish/axolotl is nearly impossible MCPE-138175 Axolotl can't be picked up MCPE-138176 I can't pick up axolotls at all MCPE-138595 Axolotls Bugs MCPE-139279 Picking axolotls up in buckets MCPE-139326 Can’t pick up axolots in buckets MCPE-139599 Axolotls and sometimes other mobs when getting picked up with a bucket will instantly come out MCPE-139664 Axolotl's very difficult to place in bucket MCPE-141245 Hi in windows 10 minecraft bds when u pick up axolotls does not get in the bucket, can u please fix this bug thanks you.

Attachments

Comments

migrated

this is kinda a bug but when your holding down place it happens so fast that it places it back down again

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

This seems to be even more noticeable in the 1.14.x betas, and affects other bucket type interactions also (lava, water, milk).

migrated

Can confirm it is happening on PS4 1.14.41

Auldrick

Also applies to axolotls in a bucket. Axolotls were introduced in 1.17.0.

migrated

This is an issue I'm having with Axolotls in the new 1.17 on Xbox One. 

[media]
Sniper1.1

I’ve encountered this on PS4 with a bucket of axolotol. One got out of his tank and it took a good five minutes to get him back because each time I scooped him up, it just put him back down again. Of course it would also leave flowing water and all the water from the failed attempts helped keep him alive, but the room ender covered in flowing water which wasn’t fun. Should’ve been a clean and easy job but this bug made it hard. If Franklin dies, that won’t be good.

migrated

This is still happening and I’m playing the latest version on a Switch.

I’ll bucket something - fish, axolotl, plain water, lava - and it will sometimes immediately empty itself again.

I feel like this may or may not be related to how difficult it has become (in my experience) to bucket something after recent updates.

 

 

migrated

Created this issue in MCPE-139664. It is being covered here.

 

Upon playing 1.17.30.23 Beta, this appears to be fixed. Axolotl went in the bucket first try.

Auldrick

Thank you for the verification. However, this ticket will remain open until the fix reaches the regular (i.e. non-Beta) release.

Sniper1.1

How many times did you test it Quinn Fox? I haven’t dealt with the betas but in the full 1.17 releases there were a few times it’d work first try. Did you test it enough to believe it works consistently or could you have gotten lucky?

Auldrick

@unknown: Don't worry, the author of this ticket is a moderator here on the bug tracker. If it isn't fully fixed, he will get it done.

[Mod] LateLag

(Unassigned)

272965, 126542

Confirmed

Multiple

Windows 10

1.17.30.20 Beta, 1.17.11 Hotfix, 1.17.10, 1.17.10.22 Beta, 1.17.0.56 Beta, ..., 1.16.100.59 Beta, 1.16.100, 1.16.200, 1.17.0, 1.17.2 Hotfix

1.17.30.23 Beta, 1.17.30

Retrieved