mojira.dev
MCPE-51416

Unable to attach lantern / bell to bottom of some blocks that are allowed in Java

The lantern & bell placement is inconsistent between the java and bedrock editions of the game
This includes but may not be limited to:

  • Flower Pot

  • Anvil

  • Chorus Flower

  • Door

  • Shulker Box

  • Azalea

  • Daylight Sensor (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Stonecutter (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Spawner (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Turtle Egg‌ (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Grindstone (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Chest, Trapped Chest, Ender Chest (fixed)

  • End Portal (fixed)

  • Enchantment Table (fixed)

  • Brewing Stand (fixed)

  • Slabs (fixed)

  • Trapdoors (fixed)

  • Campfire (fixed)

  • Lectern (fixed)

In Bedrock, the bell should not be placed on the top side of these blocks:

  • Cauldron (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Glass Panes (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Iron Bars (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Walls (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Fences (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Lightning Rod (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • End Rod (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Chain (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Composter (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Hopper (MCPE-169501)

In Bedrock, lantern & bell should be placed only on the bottom side:

  • Farmland (fixed 1.20.0.20)

  • Dirt Path (fixed 1.20.0.20)

Image attached shows all differences I've found between java(left) and bedrock(right)

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 14

I think that the trapdoors are a bug from Java. They can be opened, so I think it would make sense that the player is unable to place lanterns and bells on them.

I am on iPad Pro 12.9” Gen 1 running iPadOS 13.3. 
All of these items still can not support the bell in 1.13.1.

Still exists in 1.14.20, and also the previous releases of 1.14. I just forgot to post here it seems.

I think that both Java and Bedrock should break the lantern or bell when the trapdoor is opened, I assume Minecraft has support for that.

4 more comments

Yes, it continues to affect 1.17.40.20

Affects 1.18.10.20 beta

The list of blocks is updated. Most blocks were fixed in 1.19.60.20. New screenshots with comparison:
blocks that are still not fully fixed (screenshot Java)

[media]

The bell does not need to be placed in Bedrock on some blocks (screenshot Bedrock)

[media]

Riley

(Unassigned)

299563

Confirmed

Multiple

java-parity, parity-request, vanilla-parity

1.19.60.20 Preview, 1.19.0.33 Preview, 1.19.0.32 Beta, 1.18.33 Hotfix, 1.18.32, ..., 1.18.2 Hotfix, 1.18.12 Hotfix, 1.18.31, 1.19.41, 1.21.51 Hotfix

Retrieved