mojira.dev
MCPE-62084

Villages generate without villagers

sometimes villages generate completely empty, no villagers, iron golum, or animals in the area. no cobwebs either so its not a zombie village. so far I've only seen it happen with plains biome villages in 2 different worlds.

 

mob spawning gamerule: was left on true. survival worlds had cheats disabled.

 

when creating a new world with the same seed the village generated normally (I was in creative though, not sure if that made a difference)

Linked issues

Comments 12

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

Do you have an example seed where this is happening? Does it happen even when recreating a new world?

when creating a new world using the seed the village generated correctly.

do you have domobspawning on?

yes mob spawning is on, the rest of the world's mobs spawned just fine. just the one village was completely empty. the few other worlds I've seen this happen with were the same way.

I have experienced this, but I never thought it was a bug. The number of villagers that spawn with a village is random, and can be 0. I’ve found a village with no mobs at all, and I’ve found a village that had just an iron golem and cat, no villagers.

2 more comments

the worlds I've seen this happen in were always survival with cheats disabled, so there is no way mob spawning was off. the villages were always complete as well, so not half-generated and the worlds were never updated to a newer version either (always created and played in same version)

I found a village that generates with only one villager.
So it's not "empty", but I wouldn't consider this as normal either :

Seed : -27149278
Coords : -2929 -3335

There are small unpopulated villages in minecraft. 

I found one in a tundra not so far from another village in same biome. That tiny village has 4-5 houses with a bell and one crop plot. Loot was good. 

I thought it was not a bug but just random chance that village generate without villagers, as it happens fairly often. But then I found this comment from a comparable Java Edition ticket that states that the developers' intention is for some villagers always to spawn at the village center when a village is generated. That could be intended only for Java and not Bedrock, as the village coding seems to be different in many ways. It nevertheless seems important to consider in relation to this report.

Sandra Meister

Resolving as a duplicate of MCPE-59399.

Div

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Multiple

9.1.0

1.16.20.50 Beta, 1.16.0.58 Beta, 1.16.0.53 Beta, 1.16.0.51 Beta, 1.14.1 Hotfix, 1.16.1

Retrieved