mojira.dev
MCPE-69619

Cave sounds play everywhere

The new ambient cave sounds play repeatedly at a high rate in the End dimension, when they shouldn't at all. 

How to reproduce:
1. Enter the End dimension with sound enabled

Linked issues

BDS-6641 Undying cave ambiance problem BDS-6854 Ambience sound glitch BDS-8814 Cave sounds on the surface and in all worlds such as neather and the end and superflats MCPE-69838 Cave Sounds plays also in the Nether and End MCPE-69949 Cave Sounds Everywhere MCPE-70123 ambient sounds are played constantly MCPE-70143 Cave sounds playing constantly in any zone MCPE-70197 scary noise every time i go to my house plays scary cave noise why? it started when i upgradede my verson to this MCPE-70465 Sounds in Minecraft MCPE-70593 Crary nosie in The End MCPE-71343 Scary Noises in The Village MCPE-71615 Jukebox and cave sounds MCPE-71980 The sounds of caves can be heard behind the caves MCPE-71981 The Cave Sounds MCPE-72473 Ambience sounds going off when the player is not in a cave,underwater or in the nether MCPE-72752 new cave sounds bugged on over world after coming out of a cave, abundant amount of cave noises. MCPE-73050 Cave noises in daylight MCPE-73121 Cave noises at areas that are not caves. MCPE-73275 Cave sounds MCPE-73288 Cave noises bug MCPE-73757 Scary Cave Sounds MCPE-74181 there is cave sounds when I'm not in caves MCPE-74371 Cave sounds MCPE-74559 Enough cave noise in places they shouldn't be!!! MCPE-77715 Cave ambient in overworld MCPE-77916 Scary cave noises continue MCPE-78235 Cave Noises MCPE-79286 Cave sounds MCPE-82201 Eerie noises playing above the ground MCPE-82809 Ambient Cave Sounds MCPE-84882 Nintendo Switch Cave Sounds MCPE-85526 Not to big of a issue but kinda annoying but the cave sounds play everywere not just in caves also just a suggestion but it would be nice to have a setting to turn them off MCPE-86071 Nonsense sounds in the mesa biome MCPE-87581 Constant cave sounds MCPE-87850 Cave sounds play in flat world MCPE-89302 Cave Sounds In Superflat Worlds MCPE-89677 Cave Creepy Sound Effect still effects even if your far away from caves. MCPE-93105 Spooky Sounds MCPE-93523 Cave sounds playing above ground MCPE-94214 Cave sound problems MCPE-96596 Cave Sounds on High Place MCPE-97225 Cave sounds play when not in cave system MCPE-98344 Cave noises play outside of cave MCPE-98533 Cave sounds play when they shouldn’t MCPE-102307 Cave sounds are not just playng in caves MCPE-102392 Cave Sounds Sometimes Play When You Are Not In A Cave MCPE-102486 Cave sounds are everywhere in world. MCPE-103687 When wandering around you randomly hear cave ambience MCPE-105211 Cave Sounds Play Above Ground MCPE-105703 Cave noises playing on the surface MCPE-111927 Cave sounds play everywhere MCPE-116983 Very frequent cave noises in super flat worlds. MCPE-132152 Cave ambience can play in the end MCPE-168197 I hear Cave sounds on surface MCPE-173222 Cave Sounds MCPE-191142 Cave sound play while not in a cave?

Attachments

Comments

migrated

When playing the beta myself, I noticed it seems that the cave sounds play at set or conastant intervals as well.

MythicBurritoz

It isn't just the End or Nether. My base is underground and fully lit up, but sounds are nearly constantly playing whether I'm above or within the base.

migrated

my base is fully above ground, but i guess every 5 seconds (it is a consistant interval) a random cave sound plays. even if i'm standing in broad daylight.

 

migrated

Affects 1.16.0.63

migrated

Having trouble changing my realm to the seed I want and getting tons of errors too

migrated

in android happend to

migrated

This bug still happens, but it doesn’t as often as it did before 1.16.21. 

migrated

Can you attach a video of this bug happening in the nether and overworld? I would but it says it’s too big and I can’t compress them

migrated

extra spoopy minecraft, its apart of the halloween/spooktober update, just kidding that isn't actually a thing, but its weird that cave sounds don't just play in CAVES, CAVE sounds literally have CAVE in it, im guessing everything is a cave now? its unusual to have cave sounds playing in none-cave biomes/structures

Reisen Udongein Inaba

As of 1.16.200, you can easily disable cave noises by going into settings, going into the audio menu, and setting the "Ambient/Environment" slider all the way down to 0.

 

migrated

its not called "cave sounds" its called ambient sounds and it could play there because its ambient sounds.

migrated

Ambient sounds include cave sounds, nether ambient sounds, and underwater sounds.
Cave sounds are supposed to play only in caves, or (dark) underground spaces.

migrated

turn it off by ambient/environment 

DeeFeeCee

Affects 1.17.2

DeeFeeCee

I may have additional information for this bug. Using LukasPAH's Java Debug Screen addon, I've determined that the game considers blocks above the player when determining if they are underground. This doesn't apply specifically for the case in the end, but related bug reports were all resolved as duplicates. This list includes blocks that, when stood under, give the player the is_underground "tag", but should not:
water
lava
leaves
web
ice
anvil
brewing stand
beacon

In addition, there are some blocks that should place the player underground, but currently don't:
(moss) carpet
lectern
powder snow
end portal (frame)
composter
enchanting table
shulker box
pistons
stairs
daylight sensor
stonecutter

This hopefully explains why (in the overwold), walking under a tree or swimming underwater causes cave sounds to play.

migrated

Affects 1.17.40

1.18.0.22 beta

Reisen Udongein Inaba

Is this normal?

SmartAngel

Affects all 1.21.X versions.

[Mod] OcelotOnesie

Thank you for your report!
After consideration, the issue is being closed as Working as Intended.

Please note, that mechanics of the game may change between updates.
Things such as graphics, sounds, world creation, biomes, redstone, villagers, and animals may not work the same in current versions.

Full Version HistorySnapshot Version HistoryFeature Requests and Suggestions

Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki

migrated

(Unassigned)

340097

Confirmed

Multiple

Windows 10 Pro

1.18.0.24 Beta, 1.16.210.58 Beta, 1.16.210.55 Beta, 1.16.100.53 Beta, 1.16.100.51 Beta, ..., 1.16.40 Hotfix, 1.16.201 Hotfix, 1.17.0, 1.19.63, 1.20.10

Retrieved