mojira.dev

Dopadream

Assigned

No issues.

Reported

MCPE-128721 Break/Place sound for wheat seeds is not to parity with Java Edition 1.14. Invalid MC-223978 Bees keep leaving their hives forever Duplicate MC-152504 Sky (notably at sunrise and sunset) overlaps fog underwater Confirmed MC-135609 Cannot waterlog doors Duplicate

Comments

@MCPE4theBeacon 1.18 is out. With this time, 7 months, this simple task has NOT been ported yet.

  • Doors still use their beta sounds.

  • Trapdoors/Fence Gates also use the beta door sounds.

  • Water still has the beta splashing sound.

  • There is no underwater ambience.

  • The sound of breaking crops is outdated.

  • The sound of tilling dirt into farmland is outdated.

I'm sure there's more. I'm sure there's a LOT more if I went and checked. These are just off the top of my head.

The best part? When you report these issues, you get immediately denied with the excuse "No parity irregularities from before 1.15 are considered bugs" and they send you to their feedback page where you can say it there and hope that someone working at Mojang even sees it to begin with and decides it's worth adding.

As much as I respect your help here, you absolutely cannot say that my statement was "completely wrong". I code for Java and am well aware of how registering new sounds works. It's very easy and I can't imagine that the version of Minecraft made with a language much easier to understand would be any more difficult, unless they REALLY messed up somewhere in coding something as trivial as sound registration. 

Confirmed in 1.17.1 and 1.18 Experimental Snapshot 7 

A common issue the bedrock edition has had for years has to be the lack in updates to the sounds. Doors still use the sounds from beta, Water splashes are still the sounds from beta, Fence Gates and Trapdoors still use the same sounds as doors, and the bell sounds extremely compressed when rung. This being fixed before the release of 1.17 is unlikely, and I hope these issues get attention soon as it feels like the team behind Bedrock completely stopped caring about the sound design department of the game.

I doubt this was intentional, because the promo art for the zombified piglin on twitter shows its arms still up like a zombie.

 

[media]

Happens to me and all of my friends as well. RIP item frames.