J D

I have updated software and drivers still same issue

Thanks for the response.  CPU usage is low under 5-7-%.

Affects 1.16.40

So I had my lecterns underneath a slab in front of my librarians and it worked fine in the previous patch, but the moment this patch dropped all of the villages who had this setup were reset to normal villagers.

On top of this, a villager I had not traded with before but who had a lectern beside him (completely accessible) reset and kept resetting regularly.

I experimented with the row of villagers who had lost their jobs by:

-Increasing their stall size

-Having the lectern unobstructed  (i.e nothing in the way of the librarian to work this object)

-Ensuring the villager was "reading" the lectern to make sure he had access to it

-Faced the lectern towards the villager

Despite all this, the villagers stay as librarians but reset unless you trade with them. I initially thought that they were resetting because I was breaking the lectern from a nearby stall but I don't believe that is the case. I think they reset at the same time through some cycle despite having a lectern right in front of them with all the conditions I stated above. The stalls are completely stoned and the librarians have no access to the lecterns of other librarians.

It's worth noting that nearby villagers in stalls adjacent to the librarians are not turning into librarians. Only the villagers with access to their lectern turn into one, yet constantly reset at what seems to be a consistent cycle at the same time with other librarians.

Everybody who wants attention on this issue: VOTE AT THE TOP. That is how to get Mojang's attention.

@Peter Day

Agreed about sloppy, in general. They pushed through another cycle to give us...the carpet update? Wow...

We have told @Ezekiel this before but he does not listen. Two-finger-click for right click is incredibly cumbersome and slow in Minecraft. It also ends up spinning you through your hotbar half the time. Dumb.

@ Sky Michael Scott

There is no way to get control+click back. There might be eventually, but not now. Also please click "vote" at the top because that's the only way Mojang will consider this important.

I say we start a fund to hire the OptiFine guy to build a fix.

Wait so you're seriously not going to fix this for the new release? Well, maybe the optifine guys will work something out. The modding community has always worked much harder and been far more innovative than the MC dev team anyway (only Notch excluded).

@Grum,

Since you've got a stick up your butt about "no right click" let me bring you up to date on Apple hardware. MacBooks have no button at all. It's one big trackpad, and you can click down part of it. Rest another finger on the trackpad when you click, and you've got yourself a "right click" menu. For every function except games, this is FASTER than a windows laptop with two separate buttons, because the thumb doesn't have to move at all. It just so happens that Minecraft interprets this natural modified click by scrolling through the hotbar. An imac or mac pro, likewise, comes with a mouse capable of a traditional left and right "click", they just aren't buttons. But none of us are using a desktop--that's the point.

As for "hacks" etc, the game works perfectly in its present state. There is no weird behaviour. I can drop a single item from the stack using the K key which I have assigned that to.

@Torabi

Most of us kept starting new threads knowing full well there were others because each one we started was subsequently locked without a satisfactory answer.

this.issue.is.not.resolved.

This issue is not resolved.

Hey Grum, there's no need to be condescending. The fact is, most of us are talking about our laptop trackpad, not a mouse. On a laptop it is much quicker to modify a single button with control than it is to switch your thumb between a left and right click like on a PC laptop.

Does anyone know--is there a way to downgrade lwjgl or is that crazy? If so wouldn't that fix things for us? As far as I'm concerned, this is a game breaking issue, even if Mojang aren't responsible directly.

I don't know why this is considered resolved, this is not resolved. Using snapshot 13w17a there is no right click button mapping. Typically Button 2 is mapped to a control + click but control + click just activates a standard left click. It makes the snapshot impossible to play on a mac laptop.