The Bug
Local Brewery advancement can be obtained by pulling water bottles out of a brewing stand.
Steps to reproduce
Make sure that you do not have the advancement 'Local Brewery':
/advancement revoke @p only minecraft:nether/brew_potionPut a water bottle in a brewing stand.
/item replace block <pos> container.2 with minecraft:potion[minecraft:potion_contents=water]Get the bottle out of there.
→❌ You get the advancement 'Local Brewery'.
Expected result
Local Brewery advancement should only be received by pulling actual potions out of a brewing stand.
Actual result
You can put a water bottle in a brewing stand and immediately pull it out to get the advancement.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 22
MC-118204
Advancement 'Local Brewery' Given when placing and taking an empty bottle from the brewing stand.
Resolved
MC-118635
Skip advancement 'Local Brewery'
Resolved
MC-136228
Local Brewery Advancement if you put in and take out empty bottles
Resolved
MC-143089
Taking glass bottle from brewing stand gives Local Brewery Advancement
Resolved
MC-150371
Grabbing water bottle from output of brewing stand gives Local Brewery advancement
Resolved
17 more links
relates to 2
Attachments
Comments 25
This makes the advancement possible without even brewing anything, you just put a bottle in then right after take it out.
15 more comments
Seems to be fixed in 1.20.5, now requires the item to be minecraft:potion, minecraft:splash_potion or minecraft:lingering_potion.
What would be the intended behaviour? Only granting when removing valid potions (i.e. non water/empty bottles)?
Or something more complex where you check if the player actually started the brewing process?