mojira.dev
MC-145113

Falling blocks passengers land inside a block and not on top of block, that destroys "only one command creations" too

The bug

When summoning a falling block with another entity as a passenger (that passenger could be another falling block as well), that passenger will be inside of the block once the block lands on the ground. Before 1.14, it used to be ejected on top of the block.

Most noteworthy, this causes falling blocks riding other falling blocks to pop off as items instead of being placed, rendering so-called "one command creations" unusable.

How to reproduce

1. Example:

/summon minecraft:falling_block ~5 ~10 ~ {Time:1,BlockState:{Name:"minecraft:redstone_block"},Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:cow"}]}

→ ❌ The cow will be inside of the block once the block lands

2. Example:

/summon minecraft:falling_block ~5 ~10 ~ {Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1}]}]}]}

→ ❌ The sand blocks will be drop of the block once the first block lands

3. Example with more blocks:

/summon minecraft:falling_block ~5 ~10 ~ {Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1,Passengers:[{id:"minecraft:falling_block",Time:1}]}]}]}]}]}]}]}]}

→ ❌ The sand blocks will be drop of the block once the first block lands

Linked issues

MC-215477 Falling sand breaks if summoned riding falling sand Resolved MC-195460 Problem with command block! Resolved MC-193252 1.14-1.16.1 falling block breaks Resolved MC-153125 falling block offset issue Resolved MC-172576 Summoning an entity with a falling_block as a passenger causes the falling_block to initially spawn at the entity's feet and then shoot upwards. Resolved

Attachments

Comments 29

This, if left in the game, would break a lot of commands.

In which version exactly did this behavior first appear?

The glitch appears to have started in 19w03a.

Can confirm for 1.14 Pre-Release 5.

For those interested, I had not been able to find this bug, all I could find was a similar one with the new blocks destroying themselves.  To show what was happening when I made a new bug post, I made this video:  https://youtu.be/KpcxiOI0Bjs 

19 more comments

can confirm in 21w06a, but its slightly better. about half of the blocks break.

I added a video of it in 1.16.5, hope that's ok

Can confirm in 1.17.1-rc1. All but the bottom block turn into items

Since 23w42a (1.21) the bug is smaller.
Because the fourth block will drop only randomly not always like the versions before.

Dashel R-S

Nethonos

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Platform

Low

Block states, Entities

Minecraft 19w09a, Minecraft 1.14 Pre-Release 2, Minecraft 1.14 Pre-Release 3, Minecraft 1.14 Pre-Release 4, Minecraft 1.14 Pre-Release 5, ..., 1.19.2, 1.20.2, 23w42a, 1.21.4, 25w05a

Retrieved