mojira.dev
MC-19163

Left-click and right-click actions can happen through minecart/boat (can't break a minecart/boat by left-clicking while in it)

The bug

Prior to 1.6, one could break a minecart or boat while inside it as a simple, easy, functional way of collecting the minecart and exiting the track.

To reproduce

1. Get in minecart.

2a. Place torch on block that minecart is on (only when off-rails).
2b. Break blocks through minecart bottom (including rails).

Related issues

MC-19235 Can't break boats while in them MC-19371 Cannot break Minecarts or Boats while riding them MC-19391 Can't destroy Minecart from the inside MC-19429 Can't Break minecart when inside it MC-19601 Can not hop off minecart in 1.6.1 MC-19638 Sometimes can't break minecart while in it. MC-19795 Bug For Boats MC-19853 When you try to break a boat while in one, you can't. MC-19891 Cant Break boat while mounted MC-19968 Couldnt get out or break the minecart after starting to ride it MC-20154 Unable to break minecart while sitting in it MC-20239 Can't break or go out of a minecart when in MC-20875 Can not break or exit a minecart MC-20940 Can't break minecart while sitting in it MC-21412 Can destroy blocks under minecart while sitting in it MC-22623 Punch THROUGH the boat (causes no damage to it) MC-23007 Mine cart undestroyable/cant exit MC-23750 You can't break boats/minecarts while you are sitting in them MC-25501 Minecrarts MC-25681 Trapped in Minecart - unable to exit MC-26978 You can't break a minecart while you are inside it. MC-27014 Can't break minecart while riding minecart MC-27509 Unable to exit minecart MC-28054 Unable to exit Mine-cart MC-28085 Unable to exit minecarts MC-28431 Stuck in Minecart on Mac MC-28439 minecarts MC-31027 Smashing boats

Comments

Tails

I believe this is intended in regards to MC-13772.

Platypus

I don't think it's intended because breaking the minecart in 13w26a resulted in MC-18969 yesterday but in 1.6 you just break the block under the minecart.

kumasasa

Maybe caused by the fix of MC-12241

Tails

Actually it was MC-14355. You would always hit the horse cause of it`s large hitbox.

Anon Ymus

Confirmed.

Torabi

This sounds like an improvement to me. Now you can interact with the world without accidentally hitting your mount.

kumasasa

@Torabi: Yes, but you cannot even hit it deliberately...
In some situations it was quite handy to kill the minecart, e.g. when your train station is switched to run-through but you want to halt. Of course you can dismount by lshift, but you have to let go the minecart.

Zachary

i guess this accurately covers the issue that i have been having... i cant even play my game because of this glitch/bug. Mine occurs for the windows 7 though so I'm not sure...

Zachary

apparently you now have to use the dismount button (currently c) to exit a minecart. A warning would have been nice =P

Ezekiel

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

Dylan Rivers

Indeed it is

Achim Sinn

This just happend to me, whlie riding a boat, I think. I also experienced, that I wasn't able to move the boat siedways using a/d. Maybe that is also connected to this bug.

kumasasa

@Achim Sinn: That's MC-14521

Marios

Voted. I'm rather worried about the second part of the title, not being able to destroy a minecart while riding it. If the player doesn't have the option to break a moving minecart while riding it, then most probably it won't possible to break it after having dismounted.

BoxFigs

@Marios: Nope, you can break a boat or minecart when you're not in it (I tested it in both Creative and Survival).

By the way, when breaking it in Survival, you have to punch it a few times to destroy it instead of holding down left click, like killing a mob (probably because it's an entity; was it like that before 1.6?).

Marios

@ BoxFigs: The problem is that you cannot break a minecart while you are in it as said already. I know that it required quite a few hits to be destroyed in 1.5.2 but in 1.6.2 you can't even hit it because it acts as if it is a ghost.

Th3F4114n0n3

You guys know its because of the minecart controls change to match horses. Baisically when you ride a horse it goes from Mob to "Vehicle" and since the Minecart is already a "Vehicles" when the made it so you couldn't hit your horse when riding on it, the function became true for the other "vehicles." They made it so you couldn't accidently kill your horse when riding it and thus this happend with the minecart

Achim Sinn

Yes, I know that by now. Still I had to add Stoppers to my trainstations to prevent minecart going on, after I left them and I had to redesign my Harbor area because it was to narrow to navigate with the new boat controls and it was part of the desing to just break the boat in order to leave, which doesn't work as well.

Corgano Wade

This has made my entire rail network useless and is a pain in the ass. If I want to get out of a minecart mid track, I have to exit it, and then RUN LIKE HELL to try and catch it before it hits the next set of boosters. Why couldn't I just shift click to break it or something? Or click to break it, shift click to place things through the cart? It's the most annoying thing in the world and has made rails completely useless to me

and I LOVED rails 😞

Corgano Wade

Still an annoying issue in 1.7.4. Please fix this. It's a mechanic-breaking issue that cripples minecarts and rails

Charles Bilodeau

I cant use minecart at all :/ please fix!!!

Fred Flinstone

This is a major problem, Is there a quick fix though? I have no way to get out of my minecart. I'm stuck in the middle of perfecting my space. Lol

kumasasa

Press LSHIFT

Robin T.

Correct me if I'm wrong but ithink this is supposed to happen (new feature in 1.6) :-/ because so you can shoot throug it with a bow! also you can leave it with "crouch"

Sonicwave

Confirmed for 1.8, though may be intended.

Kraif

Confirmed for 1.13.1.

Marty McFly

Affects 1.16 Release Candidate 1

Trplob

Relates to MC-270247

Gullyman4

Platypus

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

(Unassigned)

block, boat, minecart, place, rail, torch

Minecraft 1.6, Minecraft 1.6.1, Minecraft 1.6.2, Minecraft 1.6.4, Minecraft 1.7.1, ..., 1.16 Release Candidate 1, 1.16, 1.16.2, 1.16.3 Release Candidate 1, 1.16.3

Retrieved