mojira.dev
MC-3262

Torch attached to a block with no blocks under it will not break falling sand/gravel

As first you must have at least 4 block tall.Then place torch on the third block and place sand or gravel up. Destroy the block above torch, then sand or gravel will fall down "pass" torch.

Linked issues

MC-3879 Sand and gravel no longer break when falling on torches Resolved MC-7566 Torch attached to a block with no blocks under it will not break falling sand/gravel Resolved MC-10149 Falling sand entity pass through signpost Resolved MC-20324 Falling gravel and sand can pass through torches, red torches and signs that are on a wall Resolved MC-51614 FallingSand Entities fall through all walkthroughable blocks Resolved

Attachments

Comments 6

Falling blocks are entities, which pass through non-solid blocks like mobs and players. Not a bug.

Confirmed not sure if intentional, i think it is 😃

Fora simple player who doesn't know about entities and so on, the weird thing is that regular sand sits on torches but falling sand doesn't. So this behaves somewhat inconsistent.

Didn't sand falling on a torch previously cause the sand to turn into an item? I've read about people using that as a fast way to harvest sand and gravel.

@Torabi: This seems only to happen when there is a block right beneath the torch

Sand and gravel will break if they try to land in any non-solid block. In this case, since there is an air block beneath it, it doesn't try to land there, and just falls through. It has always worked this way.

Kienose D.

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

falling_block, torch

Minecraft 1.4.5

Retrieved