[MC-36191] Missing stat.mineBlock for various blocks (mob spawners, cauldrons, beds, etc.)

Attempting to add a stat.mineBlock objective using the following blocks produces an Invalid objective criteria type error:

minecraft:bed
minecraft:brewing_stand
minecraft:cake
minecraft:cauldron
minecraft:cocoa
minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
minecraft:fire
minecraft:flower_pot
minecraft:grass_path
minecraft:melon_stem
minecraft:pumpkin_stem
minecraft:mob_spawner
minecraft:piston_head
minecraft:powered_comparator
minecraft:unpowered_comparator
minecraft:powered_repeater
minecraft:unpowered_repeater
minecraft:purpur_double_slab
minecraft:redstone_wire
minecraft:reeds
minecraft:skull
minecraft:standing_banner
minecraft:wall_banner
minecraft:standing_sign
minecraft:wall_sign
minecraft:trapdoor
minecraft:iron_trapdoor
minecraft:tripwire
minecraft:wheat
minecraft:beetroots
minecraft:carrots
minecraft:potatoes
minecraft:nether_wart
minecraft:wooden_door
minecraft:acacia_door
minecraft:birch_door
minecraft:dark_oak_door
minecraft:jungle_door
minecraft:spruce_door
minecraft:iron_door

Missing blocks (not mineable)
As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block both work, these blocks could be added as well.

minecraft:barrier
minecraft:bedrock
minecraft:end_gateway
minecraft:end_portal
minecraft:flowing_lava
minecraft:flowing_water
minecraft:lava
minecraft:water
minecraft:piston_extension
minecraft:portal

Counted within different statistics
Their own stats are missing, but they are counted as other (similar) blocks.

Affected block	Counts as
minecraft:double_stone_slab	minecraft:stone_slab
minecraft:double_stone_slab2	minecraft:stone_slab2
minecraft:double_wooden_slab	minecraft:wooden_slab
minecraft:lit_furnace	minecraft:furnace
minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp	minecraft:redstone_lamp
minecraft:lit_redstone_ore	minecraft:redstone_ore
minecraft:unlit_redstone_torch	minecraft:redstone_torch

----

Code analysis by @unknown can be found in this comment.

Linked issues

is duplicated by 9

MC-48894 blocks missing from scoreboard objective stat.mineBlock Resolved

MC-49045 Missing stat.mineBlock.minecraft.nether_wart Resolved

MC-65050 stat.mineBlock.minecraft.grass does not register when mining grass Resolved

MC-79531 Sugarcane scoreboard objective not available Resolved

MC-79642 Scoreboard bug with skulls Resolved

4 more links

relates to 1

MC-105050 Some blocks are tracked in statistics/objectives for similar blocks despite having their own space to be tracked. Resolved

Attachments

Comments 40

Anon Ymus 2013-10-20T14:46:19Z

Confirmed. Not having 380 makes sense as it is the item form of the cauldron.

Skylinerw 2013-12-08T18:19:47Z

Confirmed. Red mushrooms also present this issue, while brown mushrooms do not. I will update this comment for other blocks I find that can't be tracked.

EDIT: Confirmed for 1.7.4. Now present up to 14w06b. The exception is "flower", which has changed to "yellow_flower" and also works. The rest still do not.

Blocks you mine should be mined with the proper tool in order for it to count towards the score.

Blocks that are available to track but do not increment score:

1. minecraft:grass (2) - Not even with silk touch
3. minecraft:red_mushroom (39) - Brown mushrooms work, these do not.
4. minecraft:lit_furnace (62) - Counts as a furnace instead (61)
5. minecraft:farmland (60) - Counts as dirt (3)
6. minecraft:double_stone/wooden_slab (43/125) - The doubles count as a single slab (44/126)

Blocks that are listed as "Invalid objective criteria type":

1. minecraft:bed (26)
2. minecraft:mob_spawner (52)
3. minecraft:redstone_wire (55)
4. minecraft:wheat (59)
5. minecraft:standing_sign (63)
6. minecraft:wooden_door (64)
7. minecraft:wall_sign (68)
8. minecraft:iron_door (71)
9. minecraft:reeds (83)
10. minecraft:unpowered_repeater (93)
11. minecraft:powered_repeater (94)
12. minecraft:trapdoor (96)
13. minecraft:pumpkin_stem (104)
14. minecraft:melon_stem (105)
15. minecraft:nether_wart (115)
16. minecraft:brewing_stand (117)
17. minecraft:cauldron (118)
18. minecraft:flower_pot (140)
19. minecraft:carrots (141)
20. minecraft:potatoes (142)
21. minecraft:unpowered_comparator (149)
22. minecraft:powered_comparator (150)

Note: the above lists are not necessarily complete and will continue to be modified if more blocks are found

Skylinerw 2014-01-12T04:59:20Z

Confirmed for 14w02c/14w08a

Luke Dueck 2014-03-13T19:05:43Z

Still a Problem in 14w11b.
This would be super useful if it was fixed.

Itouch2 2014-05-10T16:26:25Z

~~You just have to use "stat.useItem.minecraft.cauldron" or "stat.useItem.minecraft.mob_spawner" instead of mineBlock.~~

30 more comments

Skylinerw 2014-05-10T16:44:47Z

@Gary, this is incorrect. "useItem" is for tracking the placement or usage of a block/item. "mineBlock" tracks the destruction. Tested in 14w19a, "useItem" does not track the destruction of cauldrons or mob spawners, which is what the issue is (which is still an issue in 14w19a).

Itouch2 2014-05-10T16:46:06Z

Ok, you're right.

The8BitMonkey 2014-06-16T10:19:57Z

Confirmed in 14w21b still unable to track the mining of mob_spawners

marcono1234 2014-07-30T17:27:51Z

Confirmed for

14w31a for mob_spawner
Minecraft 1.8-pre 1

roman seiler 2014-07-31T10:43:21Z

standing_banner and wall_banner don't work neither

Torabi 2015-02-04T16:25:14Z

I have double-checked @unknown's list for the current snapshot. Red mushrooms are fixed, double slabs now produce an error, standing_banner and wall_banner produce an error. I have not checked blocks that were not mentioned in the comments, so there may be others.

Nicolás Hurtado 2015-04-17T21:45:24Z

(Sigh) well I hope they'll fix this.... some day

Cam 2015-09-18T06:36:08Z

15w38a still affected.

marcono1234 2015-09-20T21:03:49Z

Confirmed for

15w38b For all listed blocks as well as for the blocks listed as counting for the wrong block

Missing blocks

minecraft:lit_redstone_lamp
minecraft:daylight_detector_inverted
minecraft:piston_head
minecraft:spruce_door
minecraft:birch_door
minecraft:jungle_door
minecraft:acacia_door
minecraft:dark_oak_door
minecraft:beetroots

Missing blocks (not mineable)

As minecraft:end_portal_frame or minecraft:command_block works, maybe these blocks could be added as well.

minecraft:bedrock
minecraft:piston_extension
minecraft:portal
minecraft:end_portal
minecraft:end_gateway
minecraft:water
minecraft:lava

Skylinerw 2015-12-04T01:14:47Z

Confirmed for 15w49b.

The8BitMonkey 2015-12-17T16:05:17Z

Confirmed for 15w51b

Still unable to check for mined Spawners, not had time to check others, just the one I was in need of.

The8BitMonkey 2016-01-30T21:32:38Z

Confirmed for 16w04a

The8BitMonkey 2016-02-03T21:17:49Z

Confirmed for 16w05a

The8BitMonkey 2016-02-04T19:31:46Z

Confirmed for 16w05b

The8BitMonkey 2016-02-15T23:39:54Z

Confirmed for 16w07a

starting to get the feeling this wont be fixed for 1.9 since it was reported back in 2013

marcono1234 2016-02-16T18:35:31Z

Please link to this comment in the description

The following is based on decompiled version of Minecraft 1.8 using MCP. All method and class names are the names used in the decompiled version.

The method private static void func_151181_c() of the class net.minecraft.stats.StatList which adds all the stats for mining blocks uses the item names instead of the block names. This means if a block does not exist as a block item it does not get a stat. Additionally some blocks have stats disabled using the protected Block disableStats() method.
The method private static void replaceAllSimilarBlocks(StatBase[] p_75924_0_) is responsible for the fact that mining certain blocks like lit_furnace counts as mining a furnace.

The8BitMonkey 2016-02-16T18:45:14Z

Confirmed for 16w07b

The8BitMonkey 2016-02-17T17:45:25Z

Confirmed for 1.9-Pre1

marcono1234 2016-02-17T18:32:42Z

Please link to my comment from the description

pokechu22 2016-02-17T19:40:17Z

@@unknown: Here's the obfuscated names (for mojang's assistance):

private static void net.minecraft.stats.StatList.func_151181_c(): private static void ty.c()
protected Block net.minecraft.block.Block.disableStats(): protected atr atr.J()
protected void net.minecraft.stats.StatList.replaceAllSimilarBlocks(net.minecraft.stats.StatBase[]): protected void ty.a(tq[])

The8BitMonkey 2016-02-19T19:00:23Z

Confirmed 1.9-Pre2

SunCat 2016-03-04T15:31:22Z

Confirmed for 1.9

AgentM 2016-03-05T13:20:13Z

still an issue in 1.9

SunCat 2016-03-09T19:41:58Z

Still in 1.9.1-pre1

SunCat 2016-03-12T18:02:21Z

Still in 1.9.1-pre3

tatsu 2016-04-02T15:23:27Z

Confirmed for 1.9.2

The8BitMonkey 2016-05-23T16:46:22Z

Confirmed 16w20a

tatsu 2016-06-05T16:10:02Z

Confirmed for 1.10-pre1.

The8BitMonkey 2016-07-10T14:39:44Z

1.10.2 Confirmed

SunCat 2016-10-11T21:10:03Z

Moved the list of existing but not changing objectives to MC-105050

tatsu 2017-02-04T12:04:14Z

Confirmed in 1.11.2

The8BitMonkey 2017-03-30T17:00:54Z

Confirmed 17w13a

bemoty 2017-08-12T13:15:06Z

Can confirm for MC 1.12.1.

Paint 2017-12-06T23:13:41Z

This is fixed in 17w49a, but there are two things still not right:

1. The criteria for breaking banners now exists, but never increases score (MC-122939).

2. The criteria for breaking fire exists but never increases. Is it supposed to increase score when you put out fire with your fist? Or is it not possible to "mine" fire?

All the others exist and work as intended. I tested them all. There are some that have been re-named or act differently than they were intended to when this bug report was made, but those are the only two problematic issues.

muzikbike 2019-04-09T13:48:11Z

Can confirm that the issue with fire persists in 19w14b. Should I make a separate ticket?

EDIT: New ticket at MC-147708