mojira.dev
MC-68302

Some 2D blocks models are shaded incorrectly

The bug

Since snapshot 14w25b, all 2D plants in Flower Pot, Pumpkin and Melon Stem, Mushrooms on Red and Brown Mooshroms, Redstone Repeater torch and Comparator torch models are shaded, making their textures to look darker than normal.

Fixed Resource Packs for each one (except for both Mooshrooms) can be found attached.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments

Mega611

I talk about the texture NOT about the light what emit.
Reopened now please.

galaxy_2alex

@Miguel Angel: That issue was fixed in 14w34c.

kumasasa

Left a note in MC-67830

Mega611

Look first and ultimate photo.

kumasasa

Torches and Restone torches are as bright as in 1.7.10 due to the fix of MC-67830, but not the torches on comparators and repeaters

Aaron Rhodes

The sides of blocks along the x axis are darker than the sides along the z axis in 1.8. Not sure if this is a bug or if it is intended.

Sonicwave

Confirmed for tripwire.

Bentroen

Confirmed for 15w33a and b.
Also, shouldn't the title be shortened, by replacing all affected blocks to "many transparent blocks" or something similar? Titles should be short and objective, but this one isn't being.

SteveKunG

Hi. I have attached some fix Flower Pot plant model.

Mega611

Thank you!

SteveKunG

Hi. I have attaches resource pack.
Fix included are : Repeater, Bed, Comparator and Lever.
I will take a look at Iron Bars, Stem and Brewing Stand soon.

SteveKunG

Confirmed for Stem, Brewing Stand and Iron Bars

Mega611

I have attached two bed files with ambient occlusion false.

Kraif

Confirmed for 1.13.1. Please, if you don't mind, I'd like to be the reporter of this ticket, I'll update it accordingly.

CubeTheThird

With the lighting changes introduced in 1.14+, does this issue still occur in the current release?

Capopanzone

As of 19w45b, these blocks are still shaded even if they shouldn’t:
• saplings, flowers, mushrooms, dead bushes and ferns in flower pots – inconsistent with cross-model plants including themselves when not planted in a pot
• pumpkin and melon stems (both normal and attached) – inconsistent with cross-model plants and other crops
• redstone torches in repeaters and comparators – inconsistent with normal redstone torches

Mega611

I am the original reporter and I can say that as of 19w45b this bug isn´t fixed yet, so please reopen it.

wobst.michael

@unknown, this ticket is yours again.

Mega611

I have attached some updated Resource Packs with the bugfixes. Can someone delete the old ones please? @Michael Wobst

Mega611

I don´t think that this is Work As Intended, as I reported 7 years ago in 2014 another bug related to this (MC-67830) and it got fixed. This bug should be fixed in my opinion.

galaxy_2alex

The developers have decided that for the other models, this is Intended.

ampolive

Relates to MC-129826, MC-214662 and MC-236474.

Mega611

This is not Work as Intended, as flower pots, comparators and repeaters were fixed in 24w33a. Other blocks like pumpkin and melon stem and mushrooms in red and brown mooshrooms were not fixed, so this should be reopened.

Dhranios

I'd suggest making new reports for any cases not fixed that don't have their own report yet. I know pumpkin/melon stems have their own report already.

Mega611

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Lighting, Rendering, Textures and models

block, block-entity-model, block-model, entity-model, item, redstone, rendering, texture

Minecraft 14w33c, Minecraft 14w34a, Minecraft 14w34b, Minecraft 14w34c, Minecraft 14w34d, ..., 20w28a, 1.16.2 Pre-release 1, 1.16.2 Pre-release 3, 1.16.2 Release Candidate 2, 1.16.2

Retrieved