mojira.dev
MC-89944

New boats sink and are impossible to enter underwater

When you place a new boat in 15w41b underwater, the boat sinks and when you right click it it get in, you are teleported up and away from it. The boats do not float up to the surface.

Is this intentional?

Related issues

MC-73973 Boat gets stuck underwater (submarine) MC-89949 boat began sinking and cant be re-entered, also it teleports you MC-90209 Boats don't float up when placed while in water MC-90787 Boats don't float when placed underwater MC-91243 Boat glitch 2 MC-92077 boats sink MC-92184 placing boat under water MC-92597 Bug with Boats underwater MC-96481 Wooden boat not positivly buoyant MC-108737 Boats sink in situations they shouldn't MC-110774 Boat sinks instead of rises when placed in water MC-111270 A very annoying thing is that boats can't go upstream, they can only go down. MC-112149 Boats Sink and Can't Be Moved When Ascending Water Elevator MC-118393 boat sinks MC-120835 Falling boat MC-143149 Boat got bugged MC-170643 Water flowing down pushes boat to bottom of ocean MC-201529 Boat kicks you when put in flowing water 1 block above it MC-264500 boats fall to bottom on the sea MC-269918 Boat doesn't float after getting dragged down by magma

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media]
Minecraft Derp

I can confirm.

Ely G

Confirmed for 15w42a.

Joseph Sarin

Confirmed, and boats can no longer rise up water levels so all boat elevators, log flume rides and upstream river travel are all broken now

EDIT Confirmed for 15w42a

Joseph Sarin

Still broken in 15w44a

KevinTheDruid

Still broken in 15w46a

Irbis

15w47a

Jeremy

Confirmed for 15w50a.

Joseph Sarin

Still broken in 16w02a

shufboyardee

Still in 16w03a.

Erik Broes

If you get water in the boat, you will sink.

M Payne

Grum .Your boat mechanics and physics are all wrong ! water weighs 28.316847 kg / 0.0283168 cubic meter or in Imperial approx 62 lbs per cubic foot

Archimedes' principle indicates that the upward buoyant force that is exerted on a body immersed in a fluid, whether fully or partially submerged, is equal to the weight of the fluid that the body displaces. Archimedes' principle is a law of physics fundamental to fluid mechanics.

All boat builders build their boats positively buoyant . They are designed to float if filled with water or capsized . What is the minecraft boat made from ? Lead !

Version 1.9 Pre 2 out today . Boats are broken . Have not found a way to traverse up 1 block of water . Are you waiting for the modding community to fix what you can't ? Engineers play this game as well , we're scratching our heads , we just don't understand what your trying to do with the boat .

M Payne

Lets build a minecraft boat , 6'(L) x 4'(w) x 2'(H) = 48 cubic feet , 48 cubic feet of water = approx 62 lbs x 48 = 2,976 lbs . The weight of the boat , its contents and passengers would have to exceed 2,976 lbs , to displace 48 cubic feet of water and sink . Since , when the boat sinks , it ejects its passengers and the boat is built to be positively buoyant . The boat can not sink . I can see it capsize or floating at the waterline . The boat travels down a gradient of water fine , It just can't travel up a gradient . I was told , this is the way it's supposed to be and the final release to be on Feb 25 . I Just want to know will you be releasing the final version with broken boats ?

marcono1234

You explanation makes sense, I personally think it will be pretty annoying to remove the boats once the start sinking so you will end with a ton of sunken boats at the ground of the ocean.

What you are talking about at the end is probably covered by MC-91206 (if I understood you correctly)

marcono1234

Please change the "duplicates" link to MC-91206 to "relates to"

Lewis

This was the most stupidest change. How can you talk about realistic physics when we're in a game made of blocks where I can teleport to kill a dragon? And you're changing the behavior of boats saying that if boats fill with water, they sink, as an act of making it more realistic? This is the perfect reason why I should downgrade my server to 1.8. Thanks a bunch Microsoft... you ruined Windows 10 and now you're ruining Minecraft. :/

bugsmasher

Erik Broes

Community Consensus

Minecraft 15w41b, Minecraft 15w42a, Minecraft 15w43c, Minecraft 15w44a, Minecraft 15w44b, Minecraft 15w45a, Minecraft 15w46a, Minecraft 15w47a, Minecraft 15w50a, Minecraft 16w02a

Retrieved