Only Ink Sacs you obtain by directly slaying a Squid will turn to black dye - Ink Sacs obtained by trading with a Wandering Trader will not turn to black dye, nor will they work in crafting book & quill
Also, the Ink purchased will not stack with the Ink directly obtained by slaying a Squid, nor obtained by fishing - see in picture below, none of these will stack with each other
To replicate, purchase Ink Sacs from a Wandering Trader and try to convert it to black dye and it will not - see images below
Note: This is also the case with Gunpowder
Linked issues
is duplicated by 73
relates to 2
Attachments
Comments 59

Thats really odd. Possibly is a coding error of some sort, but hey! Its the Beta so thats excpected and is ok, and will help the dev's to make the game even better!
Thats really odd. Possibly is a coding error of some sort, but hey! Its the Beta so thats excpected and is ok, and will help the dev's to make the game even better!
Thats really odd. Possibly is a coding error of some sort, but hey! Its the Beta so thats excpected and is ok, and will help the dev's to make the game even better!
Yep don't worry, it's not an issue as such but a tad annoying! I thought I was being properly smart buying ink from wandering traders! Lol, can't wait for the next patch... this patch seems to be bug central
Yep don't worry, it's not an issue as such but a tad annoying! I thought I was being properly smart buying ink from wandering traders! Lol, can't wait for the next patch... this patch seems to be bug central
Yep don't worry, it's not an issue as such but a tad annoying! I thought I was being properly smart buying ink from wandering traders! Lol, can't wait for the next patch... this patch seems to be bug central
Can confirm, 1.16.100.58
Can confirm, 1.16.100.58
Can confirm, 1.16.100.58
Yep still happening to me in 1.16.100.58 too
Yep still happening to me in 1.16.100.58 too
Yep still happening to me in 1.16.100.58 too
Yes also having this problem. Annoying
1.16.100
Yes also having this problem. Annoying
1.16.100
Yes also having this problem. Annoying
1.16.100
Checked into an nbt editor and the error seems to be in the "damage" tag. It's set to 9 instead of 0.
Checked into an nbt editor and the error seems to be in the "damage" tag. It's set to 9 instead of 0.
Checked into an nbt editor and the error seems to be in the "damage" tag. It's set to 9 instead of 0.
Can confirm it's still an issue. I thought it was odd when the ink sacs I got from squids wouldn't stack with the ones I just bought from a wandering trader, but then I couldn't use them to make bacl dye either. Version 1.16.100 on Windows 10.
Can confirm it's still an issue. I thought it was odd when the ink sacs I got from squids wouldn't stack with the ones I just bought from a wandering trader, but then I couldn't use them to make bacl dye either. Version 1.16.100 on Windows 10.
Can confirm it's still an issue. I thought it was odd when the ink sacs I got from squids wouldn't stack with the ones I just bought from a wandering trader, but then I couldn't use them to make bacl dye either. Version 1.16.100 on Windows 10.
Having this same issue in v1.16.100 on a realm, Windows 10
Having this same issue in v1.16.100 on a realm, Windows 10
Having this same issue in v1.16.100 on a realm, Windows 10
I am also having this issue on a realm on Windows 10 in v1.16.201.
Can't craft a book and quill even.
I am also having this issue on a realm on Windows 10 in v1.16.201.
Can't craft a book and quill even.
I am also having this issue on a realm on Windows 10 in v1.16.201.
Can't craft a book and quill even.
I, too am having this problem. Thank you for your help!
I, too am having this problem. Thank you for your help!
I, too am having this problem. Thank you for your help!
Just ran into this bug on Xbox One, when I needed lots of black dye for a project. Mildly frustrating to put the project on pause until a fix is implemented.
Just ran into this bug on Xbox One, when I needed lots of black dye for a project. Mildly frustrating to put the project on pause until a fix is implemented.
Just ran into this bug on Xbox One, when I needed lots of black dye for a project. Mildly frustrating to put the project on pause until a fix is implemented.
So, we've just had this happen on a privately hosted server. And as a result, have been able to isolate exactly what's happening.
May I present exhibit A which comprises 23 freshly harvested ink sacks from squid. And two stacks of 36 purchased from 2 different traders at different times.
[media]
Exhibit B - Universal Minecraft Editor
[media]
So the top one is obviously the fresh ones from squid. The other two... well notice that damage counter. This isn't the first time bedrock has had this problem so I can't say I was surprised when I saw it. The traders are literally selling damaged goods. Lol.
So, we've just had this happen on a privately hosted server. And as a result, have been able to isolate exactly what's happening.
May I present exhibit A which comprises 23 freshly harvested ink sacks from squid. And two stacks of 36 purchased from 2 different traders at different times.
[media]
Exhibit B - Universal Minecraft Editor
[media]
So the top one is obviously the fresh ones from squid. The other two... well notice that damage counter. This isn't the first time bedrock has had this problem so I can't say I was surprised when I saw it. The traders are literally selling damaged goods. Lol.
So, we've just had this happen on a privately hosted server. And as a result, have been able to isolate exactly what's happening.
May I present exhibit A which comprises 23 freshly harvested ink sacks from squid. And two stacks of 36 purchased from 2 different traders at different times.
[media]
Exhibit B - Universal Minecraft Editor
[media]
So the top one is obviously the fresh ones from squid. The other two... well notice that damage counter. This isn't the first time bedrock has had this problem so I can't say I was surprised when I saw it. The traders are literally selling damaged goods. Lol.
I love Azarel's break down and conclusion
I love Azarel's break down and conclusion
I love Azarel's break down and conclusion
It turns out that they are still useless those wandering trader
It turns out that they are still useless those wandering trader
It turns out that they are still useless those wandering trader
Just had this happen on Windows 10.
[media][media]Just had this happen on Windows 10.
[media][media]Just had this happen on Windows 10.
[media][media]The ink sacs from wandering traders can still be used to make black wool + carpet 🙂 (although still annoying, if you want to make book+quill, black dye or grey dye)!
The ink sacs from wandering traders can still be used to make black wool + carpet 🙂 (although still annoying, if you want to make book+quill, black dye or grey dye)!
The ink sacs from wandering traders can still be used to make black wool + carpet 🙂 (although still annoying, if you want to make book+quill, black dye or grey dye)!
can't get a wondering trader (from spawn egg) in 1.16.210.54 to even trade ink sacs. Might just be bad luck, but i looked at about 100 traders. non had it
The fix in 1.16.210.54 beta applies only to ink sacs acquired in that version or later. For already existing ink sacs please vote for/follow MCPE-113983.
The fix in 1.16.210.54 beta applies only to ink sacs acquired in that version or later. For already existing ink sacs please vote for/follow MCPE-113983.
The fix in 1.16.210.54 beta applies only to ink sacs acquired in that version or later. For already existing ink sacs please vote for/follow MCPE-113983.
this is because they have damage, checked using a nbt editor
The ink sacs also can not be traded back to librarian villagers
The ink sacs also can not be traded back to librarian villagers
The ink sacs also can not be traded back to librarian villagers
I've had this exact glitch also happen with cobblestone on a realm I was playing on. I have no idea what caused it.