mojira.dev
MCPE-166344

Farmer villagers won't harvest grown crops - they just stare at them

Farmer villagers are not harvesting full-grown crops, instead they freeze and stare at the crop. In pictures 2 and 3 two villagers are trying to harvest a grown carrot through a wall.

This bug occured in vanilla minecraft, no mods, add-ons or anything else is used. Mob Griefing option has always been enabled.

More info:

Check picture 4

At first, villagers seem to start harvesting the farm normally until they freeze.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Find a village (preferably a plains one){*}{*}

  2. Find a farmer & a farm **

  3. Observe the villager harvesting the farm

  4. Sooner or later the villager should freeze and stop harvesting anything.

Related issues

MCPE-166891 Villager Stops Working/Moving Suddenly MCPE-171164 Farmer villagers are either Late for farm crops, or they just doesn't move, At all MCPE-172174 Farmer villagers stand paralyzed on top of plowed land MCPE-173137 Villager won't pathfind to crops MCPE-173586 farmer villager can get stuck trying to plant a seed one block down MCPE-174036 villager "hand" too long bug MCPE-174050 Farmer Villager freezes when harvesting crops MCPE-177031 Farmer Villagers freeze into place occasionally when harvesting crops MCPE-179909 Villager not behaving right MCPE-180397 Farmer Villager Bug MCPE-182587 Villagers farmers cannot harvest a plantation MCPE-182607 Farmer Villagers won't path find through crops to pick up seeds MCPE-182727 Villagers don’t path find around water MCPE-185708 Villager intelligence issue MCPE-188289 Villager's IA works strange MCPE-189181 Farmer Villagers cannot pathfind properly when trying to harvest, or plant a crop MCPE-189363 Villager problem MCPE-189572 Farmer villagers attempt to pathfind to crops they cannot reach MCPE-194874 Village farmer paralyzed at harvest time

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media]
migrated

Do you use any packs/add-ons in your world?

[Mod] OcelotOnesie

Do you have the Mob Griefing game rule enabled?

GoldenHelmet

The cause of this issue is that farmers pathfind to crops as if the crop and farmland are located at +1 x, -1 y, +1 z of their actual positions. In other words, when they find a crop on farmland, they check for a path to within a block of the space +1 x, -1 y, +1 z of the crop instead of within a block of the crop itself. It does not matter what block is actually at the spot +1 x, -1 y, +1 z of the crop—it can be solid, air, etc.—as long as they can pathfind adjacent to that spot (even on top of it) then they will, and then they will harvest the actual crop from the offset location, even through a solid corner. If they cannot pathfind adjacent to that spot on dry ground then they will freeze, sometimes while staring at the crop. This is why the freezing happens with them staring at crops on farmland that is to the north or west of walls or water.

This issue has the same underlying cause as MCPE-166440, and it breaks micro crop farms where a farmer is trapped on single piece of farmland and dispensers apply bonemeal to grow the crop.

MCExplorer44

Temporary workaround is to give them a nudge and they will start harvesting again. Not great for a self-sufficient village but will keep them from not growing their population.

migrated

Please update the bug report and state that the bug remains today in Minecraft Bedrock Edition 1.20 versions 

migrated

Affects 1.20.20.23 Preview

Vocktile

this issue is now also more present when using villagers to plant pitcher pods a temporary fix would be making the pitcher plant bottom have no physical interactivity and can be walked through until a fix for this villager pathfinding is found.

this issue happens when the villager has to path find to a spot from farmland to farmland that has a elevation change between the two spots also gets stuck when occupying the same space as a pitcher pod a temporary partial fix would be that if a villager takes to long to attempt to plant or break a plant its trying to path find to it completes its action so long as it its current pathfinding activity has not been interrupted eg profession change, is submerged, being attacked, scared by zombie, etc etc or alternatively if it takes to long to path find it then attempts to move in a random direction  hopefully at some point walking over the obstacle and or issue.

just a suggestion

Save The Bedrock

Request to reopen

Its still there and affects 1.21.80, and it has become worse. The Villager does not move at all.

Save The Bedrock

Please ignore the Request. It was my fault

migrated

(Unassigned)

979164

Confirmed

Multiple

1.19.70.20 Preview, 1.19.60.27 Preview, 1.19.60, 1.19.73, 1.19.80, ..., 1.21.50.28 Preview, 1.21.44 Hotfix, 1.21.50, 1.21.60.24 Preview, 1.21.51 Hotfix

1.21.80.25 Preview, 1.21.80

Retrieved