mojira.dev
MCPE-18880

Fortune works on tall flowers when aiming at the bottom half of the tall flower

The fortune enchantment works on tall flowers (rose bushes, sunflowers, large ferns, etc.), which *presumably* is not intended. (Since this is not the behavior in the Java edition.) This has been happening since at least 0.14.0, possibly earlier. However, this issue was previously reported in MCPE-13304, a bug which was originally created for a separate issue where simply breaking a tall flower with anything would cause it to drop 2 of itself instead of 1. I decided to create this as a separate issue since it really isn't the same as the bug the previously-mentioned report was about.

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. Enchant a pickaxe with the Fortune enchantment (preferably Fortune III)

  2. Enter Survival Mode

  3. Break the tall flower with the pickaxe

  4. Notice how instead of dropping one flower, it drops several

Linked issues

BDS-14701 fortune work on 2 block tall flowers Resolved MCPE-56381 Breaking 2-blocks tall flower with fortune 3 tools Resolved MCPE-64498 Using a tool with fortune to break a 2 tall flower will drop more than one flower Resolved MCPE-81591 Fortune enchant works in sunflowers Resolved MCPE-82390 Fortune 3 affects 2-high flowers Resolved

Attachments

Comments 12

This is fairly reasonable, can we keep this one as a feature?

This is fairly reasonable, can we keep this one as a feature?

Can confirm this affects 1.1.0.9.

Why is this a feature? You're duping it just by mining it.

2 more comments

Mods please reopen this. Affects 1.16.101

Mods please reopen this. Affects 1.16.101

Sometime when this bug existed, pitcher plants when fully grown as a 2 tall flower did drop multiple of the same item with Fortune. This has since been fixed.

SuperGeniusZeb

(Unassigned)

48388, 307900

Confirmed

Multiple

Windows 10 Version 1607

flower, fortune, large_fern, lilac, peony, rose_bush, sunflower

1.19.0.24 Beta, 0.16.2, 1.0.0.0, 1.0.2, 1.0.3, ..., 1.2.0.22, 1.18.12 Hotfix, 1.19.11 Hotfix, 1.19.62, 1.20.32 Hotfix

1.20.70.24 Preview, 1.20.70

Retrieved