mojira.dev
MCPE-28260

Piston Crash Bug (Reproducible)

Included is a world file. There should be a piston portcullis immediately in front of the user once they spawn.

What I expect to happen: I flick the lever and the bottom piston row successfully double extends, then retracts.

What happens: If I flick the lever (might need to do so twice), the pistons in the bottom double extender row suddenly pause, then fire randomly (which they normally should not), then the game crashes, all in that order.

Linked issues

MCPE-27687 The Minecraft pe realms which I host failed to rebuild the majority of the terrain following the recent crash. All buildings and infrastructure lost. The world was simply sliced in half right down to the bedrock. Resolved MCPE-28349 Piston bug!!!!! Resolved MCPE-28974 Minecraft Crash due to entitiy processing Resolved MCPE-29241 2 Bugs of disappearance Resolved MCPE-29327 Piston Bug Resolved

Attachments

Comments 20

My survival world crashes when a row of pistons extends in the nether. Can't play it anymore unless I restore a backup of my world where I'm overworld. Perhaps our issues are the same. Same version on android. 1.2.3 on windows 10. Both crashing on piston extend.

MaladjustedPlatypus

It seems this issue, besides crashing, also results in pistons breaking each other (they drop the item, not just deletion), and pistons getting transformed into smooth stone. Basically, when multiple pistons are interacting, like double/triple extenders, and the timings are too short such that the pistons' behavior is affected by the random update order, issues begin to arise. Originally when a piston timing was affected by random tick order it would either work or not work. Now it either breaks the piston, turns it into stone, or crashes.

MaladjustedPlatypus

Affects 1.2.5.15, but requires different timings to trigger (due to the slower observers).

Just letting you know that we're looking into this.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

This can also delete chests, as shown in MCPE-29241 (Any contents will drop though, thankfully)

10 more comments
[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

@unknown, I think that is likely to be a separate bug, can you please make a new ticket for it, and add a test world please?

This bug is live again in newest beta 1.5.0.1 I use only single piston and when activate it crushes the game.

Why did you make it resolved again?? This bug is on 1.5.0.1 again, try to place a single poston with any block on front of it then powered the piston the the game will crush but if piston has noting to push it will not crush the game but if have it will crush the game, please reopened it again this bug is still have on latest beta. Please fix it

Hey developer of mojang please reopened this report this bug is on 1.5.0.1 again, I can't use piston.

@@unknown: The cause of this bug was found and fixed. Although it looks similar and might be related, the problem you're describing for 1.5.0.1 is a different bug which we're tracking as MCPE-33072. Please add your vote to that ticket.

… which has already been duplicated dozens of times. PLEASE SEARCH BEFORE CREATING A NEW REPORT, PEOPLE!

MaladjustedPlatypus

(Unassigned)

92581

Confirmed

Windows

Windows 10

1.2.5.12, 1.2.5.15, 1.2.7.2, 1.2.8.0, 1.2.9.1, 1.2.14.3

1.2.13.5

Retrieved