Some blocks don’t have the correct hitbox in bedrock edition. The following blocks are affected (list may be incomplete):
Anvils (MCPE-59921)
Beds (MCPE-60829)
Bells hanging on the ceilling or side of a block
Brewing stand (MCPE-59922)
Cauldren (hitbox doesn’t go inside it)
Composter (hitbox doesn’t go inside it)
Fences, Iron bars, walls and glass panes on a corner (MCPE-59920)
Grindstone
Hopper (MCPE-47541) Fixed in 1.16 beta
Lantern
Lectern (MCPE-47604)
Levers
Piston body (When it is extended) (MCPE-83258)
Redstone (MCPE-61245)
Sea pickle (MCPE-59925)
Sugar cane (MCPE-60827)
Walls (MCPE-55865)
This also relates to MCPE-59928, where the outline doesn’t match the hitbox on some blocks.
Attachments
Comments 8
That’s not true. This can’t be intended. This is not the case in java and for many blocks it already was reported and for some even fixed. I don’t think these wrong hitboxes are intended.
It's not a bug, but that is being changed with certain items in the 1.16.0 update. For example the hitbox of hoppers is going to be changed so they match the Java edition.
Per the notes in MCPE-13758 Mojang requested any hitbox reports to be for distinct items and to include details on how it affects gameplay for each item.
To make this easier to track, please create a new ticket for each hitbox that is not working as designed, where this adversely affects gameplay (for instance hoppers having a large hitbox means that chests underneath cannot be accessed).
Please note that "not being like Java" is not a valid qualifier for a bug. The issue would need to adversely affect gameplay per Mega_Spuds comments to qualify as a bug.
For other items where the issue is purely cosmetic I would suggest submitting feedback at https://feedback.minecraft.net
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki
Ok, I didn't know that mojang wants a new ticket for every simgel wrong hitbox. I will create tickets for the blocks that it hasn't been reported yet.
Just keep in mind my comments from above.
To be a bug it must negatively affect gameplay. Tryashtar has done an awesome job of logging the existing ones with great examples of how it affects gameplay, it may be the others haven't been logged because there's no meaningful impact caused by the current implementation.
For the piston body I created a ticket: MCPE-83258. Are there any negative affects from the wrong hitboxes for bells and other blocks?
This is supposed to be its not a glitch