I can't post on the feedback website

Sr Kumasasa this post is not duplicated, the post you put like "duplicated by" is for an sign in error my problem is not a sign in error is a posting error.

This also happened to me, but the feedback was copied by somebody else. I AM SO ANGRY BECAUSE THE COPY NOW HAS 1200 VOTES AND WAS A PINNED TWEET BY MCPE BETA!!!

Please fix this error in your feedback website.

Mojang really needs to look into what is happening. Every single one of my posts, not including comments, have gotten removed or were unapproved and no email was sent at all or as for why it was. I think somebody is doing this on purpose and I am getting impatient. People are able to post suggestions and I am not. It is getting hurtful.

@Ayden that is super scary. I hope mine didn't go through that. I can't find out what happened to any of mine either! Please mojang, please fix!!

Happens to me too, on every post I make no matter how good the content is. It gets stuck on "Pending approval" for a week or two and then it completely disappear as if I never posted it, URL becomes unreachable, only the image URLs can still be accessed manually. No info on why it was "deleted" is provided, and when I contacted support, I got quite a generic reply about guidelines (that I'm sure I followed well).

This issue was submitted more than two years ago and the problem still occurs. It seems like a pretty serious bug. But have the devs even acknowledged it?

@Ayden: What feedback was it?

rofl... i just noticed they deleted all my posts suggesting new content...

Wait, you guys can actually sign in!? Every time I try to sign in, it acts like it works, but then I’m not actually signed in. It’s been this way for over a year and I’ve tried to contact customer support several times, but they never responded. There was a post on this site regarding that issue but a mod just said to contact customer support (even though I said I’ve tried and got nowhere. They then just linked some article saying they were experiencing high contact volume. I understand delay, but months?) and closed the issue. Oh, and all my posts and comments are gone. They don’t seem to exist anywhere. It’s like the account got deleted, but I didn’t do that. The Microsoft account associated with it works elsewhere. I’ve been able to ignore it but with 1.17 coming, I don’t think I can keep doing that. I used to post, comment, and vote often, but I can’t do that anymore. I don’t know exactly when it happened, but I know I used to get a bunch of emails from the posts I was subscribed to (although, many where just saying my post was removed because insert vague list of possible reasons). One day I was like “hey, wait a minute. When’s the last time I saw one of those emails? They used to come in daily.”. So, I went to the site and boom, couldn’t sign in.  It’s been over a year and I’m still without help, so anything would be nice. The feedback site is just... annoying. Like, when I could actually use it, so many of my posts were removed for seemingly no reason. I think once they linked me to a similar post, but other than that it was just “here’s a list of reasons it may be removed. You don’t think you violated one of those rules? Well, you probably did but we won’t tell you what.” Oh, and let me access the removed post for a few days after removal so I can use similar arguments elsewhere or something. Sorry, that started a rant. I’m just so tired of this issue.

My feedback and my comments all got deleted within minutes of posting them, it doesn't seem like anything I post will ever make it out of "Pending Approval"

I have the same issue. It gets to "Pending Approval" and the disappears a few hours later at most

Is this still an issue for anyone?

well for me sorta

Yes, it still is. The worst part is that it's somewhat inconsistent. I managed to post something last week, but nothing since then has worked

I am glad I found this. Thought I was the only one. I even made a new account and still have the same problem. Uploaded my idea around 7 pm ish and it said pending approval for A few hours and poof disappeard. No email or explanation, it felt like my ideas were so stupid that it was just deleted.

This didn't happen to me, instead WEB-4529 does

All of my posts are gone?

This also happens to me. I just made https://feedback.minecraft.net/hc/en-us/community/posts/5870560958605-Sane-Complete-License-For-Minecraft-Pi-Edition, it was "Pending Approval" for a few minutes, then it was just gone! I checked my email (and junk email) and got absolutely nothing! I literally use a Microsoft email account, there's no reason any emails should be blocked!

Having some issue here. Posted 3 ideas and my 3 posts idea got "Pending Approval" and i waited for mods open public but my 3 posts got deleted for no reason even my posts isnt got duplicate or unhelpful but they mods thinking i did.

Had that happen 3 times. Followed every rule, selected right topic, but still continued to happen. After waiting a few months I was able to post though.

issue still happens. everything i did on the feedback site except for my votes and 3 comments were deleted, and a comment that never made it out of pending approval that i spent so long on was deleted for no reason! to make things worse, my real name now shows as my username! this bug should really be looked into more as the feedback site is barely worth using while this bug is prevalent!

edit: it appears i was affected by WEB-4761 with the name thing, and my activity was not affected. not saying this shouldn't be fixed though!

I think there is still an issue regarding Feedback and Zendesk emails. 

Proof: https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/zdzkc6/why_do_you_still_post_your_ideas_here/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Oh someone has posted this. I never knew this bug has affected others as well. About 3 years ago I think I had all my posts removed and I couldn't see my comments either. I was one of the most active posters there at the time and had probably 100-200 suggestions so it really hurt, especially since I had no backups. I tried to communicate the mods and admins, but got no response so I just gave up. All that effort went to waste.

This happened to me today. I spent such a long time figuring out what to say in a comment that by the time i hit Submit hours had passed and there was a whole new page of comments under the post. Pasted my text back into the box and hit Submit again, now I'm at least at "Pending Approval". Wonder what changed that made it work the second time.

Edit: Just realized that I forgot to bold some sentences when I resumbitted it. Maybe that has something to so with it?

The automod seems to have really dumb settings.  Because this "

These changes wouldn’t be so bad, if the chances of zombie villagers spawning were greater in jungles and swamps. Then the discount would already be known when rerolling to get the best price.  Since the jungle and swamps are hot and humid biomes, any abandoned wooden structures would rot away in short order. These biomes could have ghost villages in them. A damaged well and cobblestone fence posts that could have been the foundation of stilt houses. These villages could also spawn zombie villagers at night, since ghosts come out at night, which could be cured for villager trading halls.  Some buried barrels or chests in the ghost villages that have a couple of the biome specific books for those that play on peaceful. And possibly encourage loitering after dark.  Have chiseled bookshelves generate in villager libraries that have a book with a poem or a riddle alluding to the ghost villages in swamps and jungles.

"I once heard of a group of villagers that mended and hardened tools. They made their home deep in the steamy areas. I wonder if a visit will find them once more. Oh, oh oh, and melons!"

has been "pending approval" for 11 days now.  I'm fairly certain at the 14 day mark, it will disappear without any reason being given.

Even dumbing it down to sound like an angry 12 year old typed it didn't post either. 

More zombie villagers in swamps andn jungleghost villages with fence an well remains zomb villagers at night submerged berrals with books pieceful players poem or riddle alluding to villages

Yet there are posts with walls of foreign text, others with bullet points and other thoughts formatted similar to my post that actually posted.  Are US ip address more censored than the rest of the planet?  There seems to be absolutely no point in thinking through an idea for DAYS and editing it for ease of reading is rewarded with the post being deleted.   I've posted several ideas over the course of a couple years and NONE have posted.  STOP SOLICITING FOR FEEDBACK IF YOUR NOT GOING TO ACCEPT IT!!

I know right? If you're not going to accept new feedback, and ever worse: DELETE WHAT WE ALREADY POSTED, then what's the point of having the feedback site? I have a bunch of small QOL tweaks that would be perfect for the game and tried posting them on the site, but found most of them disappearing without a trace after a few days of being pending. Surely this is a bug, or if not at least send an automated email as to WHY our ideas are being deleted without a trace. Something as simple as "we deemed your post too similar to an existing idea" (WITH A LINK) would prevent a lot of angry users. Ironically, I posted this idea and it too was deleted 

Just had this happen to me today too 2 of my suggestions, Preevaluated Custom Entity Selectors and Custom Gamerules. I refreshed the pages today to see if they would have been accepted yet, but as you can see if you go to them now, they've been deleted from the server and my activity page. Some kind of email of removal and why would make this a lot less infuriating, and I'm surprised that this isn't "important" priority.

how is this wai? it should not be

Posts are removed due to being moderated or duplicates. You will need to search before making a post on the feedback website to make sure it's not already been suggested.