mojira.dev
MC-110400

Shulker boxes can be opened when blocked by certain blocks

When the following blocks are on top of a shulker box, it can still be opened.
The affected block:

  1. Banner

  2. Cobweb

  3. Sapling (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  4. Snow layer (layers: 1)

  5. Vines

  6. Sign

  7. Lever (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  8. Pressure plate (all)

  9. Torch (redstone) (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  10. Button (all) (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  11. Fence gate (opened)

  12. Redstone wire

  13. Rail (all)

  14. Sugar canes (Fixed)

  15. All crops (wheat, melon, pumpkin, carrot, potato, nether wart, beetroot) (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  16. All bushes (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  17. Mushroom (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  18. Tripwire

  19. Tripwire hook

  20. Seagrass (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

  21. Grass & flowers (Fixed in 22w45a vertically)

Linked issues

MC-133220 Shulkers boxes can open with 1 layer on top of them, but can't with 2+ Resolved MC-155882 shulker boxes can go through some blocks Resolved MC-156659 Redstone doesn't break after Shulker Box has been opened. Resolved MC-162894 Seagrass on a Shulkerbox goes through the Box when Open Resolved MC-166153 Shulker & Torch Bug Resolved

Attachments

Comments 35

is this a new bug on the minecraft jira??

The environment is supposed to only contain pc details.

Confirmed/Reproduced for most of the things on the list in 20w27a.

Already Fixed:

  • Dead Bush

  • Mushrooms

  • Sweet Berry Bush

  • Melon Stem

  • Pumpkin Stem

  • Nether Wart

  • Saplings

 

Can confirm in 20w51a.

25 more comments

This behavior has changed in 22w45a; now (most) blocks that require support are dropped when the shulker box is opened.

They're still affected if the shulker box is sideways, and they're not attached to it though (like in the screenshots).

This still remains an issue for saplings, levers, torches, buttons, crops, bushes, mushrooms, and seagrass; it's just that in 22w45a, it was indeed fixed for these blocks, but only if they were placed above or below shulker boxes.

In other words, shulker boxes placed horizontally can still be opened when blocked by these blocks. I've updated this ticket accordingly.

the rest can be confirm in 1.20.4

Can confirm in 1.21.4.

BBLZ

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Gameplay

Low

Block states

shulker_box

Minecraft 1.11, Minecraft 16w50a, Minecraft 1.11.1, Minecraft 1.11.2, Minecraft 17w06a, ..., 1.20.1, 1.20.4, 1.20.6, 1.21.4, 25w03a

Retrieved