mojira.dev
MC-149

Powered pistons drop as items in creative

When I placed down a piston and it was powered by a Redstone torch,I expected that when I destroyed it that it would disappear as I was in creative mode however the item was dropped as if I was in survival mode.

To repeat this glitche place a piston down in creative mode,power the piston using any kind of Redstone such as a torch or a switch, while still in creative mode destroy the extended arm of the piston and you will see that the piston item will drop

Related issues

MC-1129 Pistons dropping as resources on creative MC-1210 Extended piston creative bug MC-1714 Getting a piston when breaking a powered piston MC-1790 if you break a activated sticky piston in creative mode, it drop MC-1928 In creative, breaking the extended part of a piston/sticky piston, will drop an item. MC-2615 Extended piston drop itself MC-2944 You can collect redstone blocks in creative MC-4950 Breaking the bottom of the piston doesn't make it drop itself, but breaking the top arm does. MC-4961 Getting Piston drop in Creative mode. MC-5141 Destroying the extended part of an extended piston gives the entity to the player MC-5388 Piston item drop in creative MC-7072 Activated pistons in creative MC-7974 Pistons dropping as items in Creative MC-8154 Breaking the arm of an extended piston causes the piston to drop as an item MC-8404 When hitting the extended part of a piston in Creative Mode, a piston drops MC-8421 Extended Piston Drops Block when destroyed in Creative MC-9713 In Creative mode, when breaking an extended piston, the piston drops. MC-10100 Issue with pistons MC-10407 MC PistonBug MC-11290 - MC-11451 When in Creative mode, breaking an active pistons head will drop a piston MC-11581 [MC 1.5pre] Sticky piston drop when removing piston while is powered in creative mode MC-11800 Pistons drop in creative MC-12181 Break extended piston in creative will return a piston MC-15267 Piston glitch in creative mode MC-16035 pistons glitch MC-21948 Piston Bug

Comments

Yoann Petremann

I don't know if there is such system, but I think minecraft must have a better block destroy recursion :
for now it seem that your piston is like broken by natural reasons since you broke it in creative.
so I think the extended part of the piston must destroy the base by giving the "reason" when it is broken.

kumasasa

Is this still an Issue in 1.4.4 ? I cannot reproduce it.

Tails

Confirmed in 1.4.6.

Jesper the End

confirmed for 13w07a

James

Confirmed for 13w09b

mike

Confirmed for 1.5 official

szczerbiec811

dd

Danny Redmond

what the hell do you mean by that?

Daniel "Glampkoo"

Cannot reproduce in 1.5.1 this should be marked as fixed in 1.5.1

Tails

Place a piston, power it, destroy the extended arm. Piston drops as item.

Danny Redmond

i can confirm that this is still a bug affecting 1.5.1

Eder Simon

Yes i have the same problem in the version 1.5.1

fake fakes

Still in 13w19a

Alex Collins

Still in snapshot 1.6.1.

Jesper the End

oh come on mojang, this shouldn't be so hard to fix. You fixed the doors too right?

kbk

While this is being fixed, I'd like to ask one more time why can not one obtain pistons (ID 29 or 33) via pick block from extended piston arms blocks (ID 34) yet, esp. in creative mode, as I wrote earlier [MC-15099] (and was misunderstood, probably).

brunost77

This bug are in 1.6.1 (The horse update) too!

i have made a youtube video about it! 😃

valery saevang

how do you download this???

qmagnet

Bug has made a return in 14w33c but only using setblock or fill. Also appears in any gamemode.
I'm not sure if this should be reopened or just start with MC-67641 clarifying setblock as the culprit.

Stanley

I'm not sure if this is reported for PC or mcpe 0.15.0, and I don't want to repost the same bug, but it happens the same in 0.15.0 update.

kumasasa

@unknown This site is the bug tracker for MCPC. Please use https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE for MCPE

Danny Redmond

Jens Bergensten

Confirmed

Minecraft 1.4.1, Minecraft 1.4.2, Minecraft 1.4.6, Minecraft 1.4.7, Snapshot 13w02a, ..., Snapshot 13w18c, Snapshot 13w19a, Snapshot 13w21a, Minecraft 1.6, Minecraft 1.6.1

Minecraft 1.6.2

Retrieved