mojira.dev
MC-233181

Kills with end crystals are not logged in statistics

Killing mobs / players by hitting a end crystal by hand / weapon or projectile is not logged as a kill in statistics.

To recreate Place a end crystal next to / near target and shoot with a bow.

Video see any video uploaded by Mumbo Jumbo HC8

Attachments

Comments 11

I think the reporter expects end crystals to work like TNT: if you ignite TNT with a flint and steel (or an arrow), you receive kill credit for anything that dies in the TNT's explosion.

For what it's worth, indirect tnt kills being credited in stats is the exception rather than the rule.  Killing something with flint and steel, lava bucket, pushing it off a cliff, etc., all are not regarded as player kills.  This is very useful for disposing of villagers, iron golems, pillagers, etc. without having to work around problematic side effects.

@@unknown, flint and steel, lava bucket are not regarded as player kills, just because the game can't record which block is placed by which player.

However, it can be done for TNT and end crystal.

@Dl if you did it by recording who placed the block, now you'll be getting player kills from magma blocks, wither roses, etc. which wouldn't really make much sense.  Still, the question isn't really whether it can be done, it's a question of whether it makes any sense.  Attaching kills to the person who placed a block would, I think, be quite odd (or at least make stats even less useful - I didn't really kill all of the creepers in the creeper farm, but I did place the magma blocks....why should that count?).  Also of course end crystals are entities when you place them, which is quite different from tnt which is placed in block form.

1 more comments

Must be the latter, or the former hit sets the "escaping from" entity. Regardless, it should be treated as a player kill in both cases, just like how manually igniting tnt and killing anything with that counts as a kill

Fixed for 1.19.3 (not sure what snapshot)

I cannot reproduce this issue in Minecraft 1.20.5 pre-release 1.

This not happening, not sure how/why this is still open after all this time.

This has been fixed in 22w43a:

[media]

Shourin

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

(Unassigned)

1.17.1

22w43a

Retrieved