mojira.dev
MC-258937

Chest model and texture in Boats with Chests have the 'bottom' and 'lid' parts separated, despite not being meant to be animated

In minecraft's code and files, boat with chests have their own chest texture and model. Its purpose for replacing the original chest model is unknown for me, but it may be a leftover from a developer's testing that somehow made it into the release. Minecarts with Chests and Boats with Chests are not meant to have animations nor sounds (as said in MC-173400 and MC-249383's resolution), so it seems a bit incoherent to have a model with 'animable' pieces.

Also its texture mapping is inconsistent with other chests on minecraft, wich may confuse people that make resource packs.

This is not a duplicate of MC-249378 since this bug is about the model and its "extra" unnecessary code on the chest boat model, not about the texture itself not having a christmas variation. Thought all this could be invalid, I'm not completely sure if it really is, so the confirmation statuts would depend.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 7

What is "the 'bottom' and 'lid' parts separated", I don't understand this issue.

It's a technical detail; they're saying that the chest has 3 elements (bottom, top and hatch) just like normal chests, but since there is no opening animation, the bottom and top element should just be 1 single element. Doing so will effectively reduce memory usage every so slightly

Ok, now I can confirm this issue.

This is not a bug.

It is redundant rendering, wasting memory, though.

I don't understand why this isn't a bug, it is reminds me of MC-205629 and that one was considered a bug. I think I will prepare a better explanation demonstating what Dhranios said.

Can confirm - this issue is still present in 1.21 as detailed and demonstrated here: MC-273540.

This issue is also related to: MC-14983

ISRosillo14

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Textures and models

1.19.3

Retrieved