mojira.dev
MC-57899

New line of vision hitbox / direction tag is incorrect for some entities

The new direction hitbox animation is incorrect for at least the following entities:

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 30

For arrows I think it would make sense because they have a direction

Is it a "direction" indicator or just the line of sight ? Look at a mob, the line is coming out of the eye level lines and turning with the head of the mob but does not indicate the direction of movement of the mob.

But a arrow in the ground is also not moving but has a "direction" where it is pointing to

Item frames have also this line so I think it is more a direction indicator

20 more comments

Well, you may have meant to say something different, but those statements are actually equivalent. Your statement says "not incorrect", which is a double negative, so your statement can be reduced to "Items having random line of sight is correct." "Items having random line of sight" is what this bug is about, and you are saying that it's correct.

Affects 1.8.7.

I believe that arrows are the most bugged here. The rest sound like they may be intended.

Well I don't really know if it should but items actually have random line of sight when dropped. You can verify this by testfor command with rotation arguments. (Or empty entitydata command) So my point is that Item having random line of sight is not a bug.

I think this bug should be split up into separate reports. Items, Lures, ThrownPotions, XPBottles, XPorbs, Fireworks, and Minecarts may well be intended. There's no clear direction they "should" face, and there isn't that much use in having a line of sight for those items. On the other hand, Arrows, Horses, and Enderdragons have a clear direction they are facing, and the line of light should work for them.

Also, does this occur with boats?

@unknown: You may create a new ticket for arrows, ender dragons and boats after confirming for each one that they are in fact still affected.

edit: Arrows are MC-74632.

marcono1234

Erik Broes

Confirmed

direction, hitbox, line

Minecraft 14w25b, Minecraft 14w26b, Minecraft 14w27a, Minecraft 14w27b, Minecraft 14w28a, ..., Minecraft 1.8.1-pre2, Minecraft 1.8.1-pre4, Minecraft 1.8.3, Minecraft 1.8.7, Minecraft 15w32b

Retrieved