The skins from some Marketplace skin packs cannot be seen by other players if they have the "Only Allow Trusted Skins" option enabled.
List of affected skin packs (may be incomplete):
Star Wars
Builders & Biomes
Crafty Costumes
YouTube Creators
The World Warrior
Rockin' Holiday Skins
Skin Pack 1 - Classic
Magic: The Gathering
Campfire Tales
Strangers - Biome Settlers 3
Toy Story
Original Description:
I purchased the new Star Wars Mash-Up pack, and it’s of amazing quality. However, one thing that absolutely breaks it for me is that players that aren’t your friends cannot see the skins.
They need to add you, then restart their games in order to see the skins. This can be very annoying for many players that want to see the skins, but can’t because of a glitch.
That’s really it.
Linked issues
is duplicated by
BDS-10953
Skin
MCPE-109621
Star wars pack no matter what skin you use you look like steve
MCPE-110786
Player 1 skin not showing in local multiplayer and custom skins not loading
MCPE-113466
Friends can not see skins from Star Wars Mash up Pack. PS4
MCPE-114760
Star Wars Mashup
MCPE-116121
starwars mashup pack skins not visible to other players
MCPE-161634
Strangers Biome Settlers 3 not recognized as a trusted skin
MCPE-167775
Toy Story Skins
WEB-3693
Glitch on Star Wars Pack
relates to
Comments
GoldenHelmet
GoldenHelmet
After looking at similar reports for other skins and retesting, I've determined that this issue relates to a profile setting. You can see the Star Wars skin of another player who is not on your Friends list if you turn off the "Only Allow Trusted Skins" toggle in Settings>Profile. I still think this may be a bug because I would expect Marketplace skins to be trusted.
migrated
Confirmed in 1.16.201 Hotfix by connecting via LAN from iOS with no Microsoft account to Windows 10 PC player who was using the Obi-Wan Kenobi skin. He looked like Steve to the iOS player.