mojira.dev
MCPE-161197

Large mobs can ride in boats/minecarts

Update from @unknown
Issue Summary:
Some mobs have too big a hitbox and are visually too big to ride in a boat/minecart. This causes an access issue (cannot be broken/get on the boat) to the minecart/boat, and also creates a visual problem as the mobs goes out of the boat/minecart.

Issue only for minecart:

  • Guardian

  • Turtle

Issue for both boat and minecart:

  • Spider

  • Hoglin

  • Zoglin

  • Ravager

  • Slime (third size)

  • Magma Cube (third size)

  • Elder Guardian

  • Ghast

  • Iron Golem (MCPE-67223)

  • Sniffer

  • Camel

  • Polar Bear

  • Mule/Donkey/Horse

Mob that should be able to interact in boat/minecart :

  • Panda (Boat and Minecart)

  • Mule/Donkey/Horse (Interact in Minecart only)

  • Turtle (MCPE-65719) (Boat only)

  • Iron Golem (MCPE-67223) (Interact in Minecart only)


Steps to reproduce:

  1. Place the boat/minecart.

  2. Pick the mob that have been listed above.

Observed results:
Certain large mobs can get into the boat/minecart.
Cannot interact with boat/minecart with large mob inside.

Expected results:
Certain large mobs cannot get into the boat/minecart.
Can be interact in boat/minecart with large mob inside.

Note:
Baby mobs that from the larger variants can grow inisde boat/minecart and become bigger inside boat/minecart.This shouldn't be happen because their hitbox will be larger inside the boat/minecart then you will be unable to interact and have some visual glitch.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 29

This is not a bug, but a game feature.

All of these mobs can ride regular boats and also minecarts. It is not clear why you think this is a bug.

The report have been updated.

I guess the large mob maybe kind of weird of how it board the boat chest.Can confirmed

I've updated the report to better describe problem.

19 more comments

The fix is correct only the interaction issue in minecart not yet fix.

To get a mob out of a minecart use an activator rail or a leash. There is no need to hit the minecart.

This is invalid as it is a feature request.. also, based on the phrase "Can't interact with boat/minecart with large mob inside".With all large mob are possible to broken/get on the boat and break minecart from below

See:
Player can break boat/minecart from below (hoglin and zoglin)

[media]

Player can break boat/minecart with large mob inside.. even ghast (video)

https://1drv.ms/v/s!AgmlsmzcEAqljALSz8Fpd6mmtzr_

[media]


In the video you can see that the player does not have enough knowledge of how the boat works, since the skeleton horse can be removed from the boat by breaking the boat from below.

In my honest opinion, I don't see why the camel shouldn't be on bamboo rafts, it looks very good and also knowing that you can access boats from below it looks very good

[media]

Player breaking bamboo raft and climbing on it, also breaking mining cart with camel inside it (video)

[media]

Picomos plays

(Unassigned)

964230

Confirmed

Multiple

hitbox, interaction, vanilla-parity

1.20.40.20 Preview, 1.20.10.23 Preview, 1.20.10.21 Preview, 1.20.10.20 Preview, 1.20.0.20 Preview, ..., 1.20.60.22 Preview, 1.20.50, 1.20.60.25 Preview, 1.20.60.24 Preview, 1.20.51 Hotfix

1.19.80.20 Preview, 1.19.80

Retrieved