mojira.dev
MCPE-169754

Carried models of some items will be larger when using any HD texture pack

I have reported the bug in MCPE-169734, However the page became invaild because it was identified as a bug of the texture pack issue, but actually the bug is a general bug of game. I just gave an example by using an HD pack from Marketplace. ALL of HD texture packs when you use then the bug will happen and only happen in Preview 1.20.0.21. In addition, the higher resolution of pack for using, the bigger items in your hands will be.

I am a 3rd party texture pack creator so I can make sure that this is a game bug instead of resource pack! 

 

Vanilla items are not data-driven so that we can not fix it through resource pack, except using attachable... That is so annoying.

 

That is the detail:

When I use HD texture pack, some items in my hand, their models became bigger than vanilla resolution in both first person and third person. Meanwhile I also found that the bobing and interacting animation of the items are different from before.

Here is the item list that I have found:

  • Kelp

  • Sugar Cane

  • Campfire

  • Soul Campfire

  • Brewing Stand

  • Item Frame

  • Redstone Repeater

  • Redstone Comparator

  • Hopper

  • Glowing Item Frame

  • String

  • Cauldron

  • Cake

  • Music disc (Including all variants)

  • Nether Sprouts

  • Flower Pot

  • Chain

  • Warped Fungus on a Stick

  • Coal

  • Charcoal

  • Snowball

  • Arrow (Including all potion variants)

  • Apple (Added in 1.20.50)

  • Trial Key (Added in 1.20.60)

  • Wind Charge (Added in 1.20.70)

  • Wolf Armor (Added in 1.21.0)

  • Ominous Trial Key (Added in 1.21.0)

  • Bundle (Added in 1.21.30)

Related issues

BDS-18549 Items appearing weirdly in hand BDS-19641 Charcoal oversized MCPE-171265 Giant String MCPE-171308 Image and Item Size Issue MCPE-171417 Hopper looks huge in hand on inventory screen MCPE-171451 Certain held items appear huge at higher texture resolutions MCPE-171574 Hopper covering inventory screen while in hand MCPE-171753 Flower pot when pick up is bigger than normal MCPE-171777 More huge items! MCPE-171914 Some held items grew by 5x their normal size when using texture packs MCPE-171925 Jumbo items MCPE-172326 Hopper becomes huge for other players. MCPE-172446 Redstone repeater is very big in hand MCPE-172702 Texture Pack holding a item problems MCPE-172806 Sugar Cane & Kelp are both too big MCPE-173069 Some textures becoming big since recent mc version MCPE-173129 item size is larger than normal MCPE-173339 Cauldron Look big in texture pack MCPE-174081 When loading a texture pack, some textures may be massive or oversized. MCPE-174706 Error displaying items in hand MCPE-174794 Some items appear giant to others MCPE-174795 Items like the Cauldron, Coal, and Item Frame appear giant compared to other items. MCPE-175628 In-hand items render extremely large MCPE-175675 Cursor is stuck as a game arrow MCPE-175901 Custom items showing extremely huge for some reason... This wasn't a problem in older 1.20 versions... MCPE-176511 Some Textures Won't Scale When Holding [unable to recreate] MCPE-176546 Some items like string and sugar cane are humongous MCPE-177386 Large ítems in hotbar MCPE-177781 Large Apple? MCPE-180829 Huge items in 32by32 and above texture packs 16by16 texture packs do not have this issue MCPE-181333 the higher the resolution u choose on texture pack the bigger certain items will be like snow balls MCPE-183374 If you put a super realistic texture pack and have a specific item, it will become huge and will not be displayed from a first-person perspective. MCPE-184150 Visual bug MCPE-187250 Most HD textures have oversized textured items MCPE-188078 Texture problem MCPE-189852 Breeze Rod Model doesn't work with Larger Textures MCPE-190706 Texture pack issue MCPE-201590 In MCPE 1.21.80.25 if you hold a Sugarcane and Apple the icon will appear big, if you check the inventory (character) the apple or Sugarcane appears big. MCPE-203805 Items to big MCPE-218086 Some items when using resource packs are massive!

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media]
v-baslod

Thank you for your report!

However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response.

Could you please provide examples of 2-3 different HD texture packs with which this issue can be observed?

This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📓 Project Summary – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki

[Mod] LateLag

Reopened; reporter already specified that it occurs with any resource pack that uses resolutions higher than the default 16x.

ZCYF

still happen in Preview 1.20.0.22

ZCYF

still happen in Preview 1.20.0.23

ZCYF

Still happen in Preview 1.20.0.24

ZCYF

Still happen in Preview 1.20.0.20

[media]
LORENTZE

Hello, I'll try to identify the problem, let me know if you have a different idea.
The HD texture pack changes the resolution of the item (e.g. 16*16 becomes 32*32) to cause the game to want to render, but due to pixel size adaptation issues, the item looks larger.

您好,我来试着鉴定问题,如果您有不同的想法,请告诉我。
高清纹理包因为物品的分辨率发生了变化(比如16*16变成32*32)为导致游戏想要渲染,但因为像素大小适配问题,从而导致物品看起来显得更大。

ZCYF

Still happen in 1.20.0 Release

JervieA20

Affects in 1.20.1, 1.20.10.24 & 1.20.10.25 Preview

JervieA20

Affects in 1.20.20.20 Preview

FoundMusician89

Affects in 1.20.10

David-Nornal

Affects in 1.20.20.21 Preview and 1.20.20.22 Preview 

owlfalls35

it only affects snowballs in 1.20.10 and newer not 1.20.1

migrated

Still happen in Preview 1.20.30.24. This problem is also happens with HD resolutions of items from mods.

migrated

Still happen in Preview 1.20.40.20

[media]
HARYAMC_

Affects in 1.20.40.21 Preview

migrated

This issue is still happening to my game on Windows.

PikachuGabe

perhaps i came here for help or maybe it was to try to get this bug fixed sooner, dont really know, but there is a texture pack made to fix this bug although in a bit of a janky way. 
the hopper block was missed in the texture pack and snowballs and arrows dont get fixed with the same method, so i tried to make a modified version and i fixed hoppers using the existing code, but i havnt been able to fix snowballs and arrows. 
i dont know much about bedrock texture packs or making anything for bedrock in general and it took a lot of research just to get it to slightly work on snowballs, and i was hoping to see the work i cannot complete can be completed by another, so i tried reaching someone smarter than me. the maker of the fix texture pack has messages off, and none of the texture pack servers i was in could help, so ig im here now.
this is the original texture pack
and this is my modified version
this image is how far ive gotten in fixing the issue

[media]
migrated

affects 1.20.50 and 1.20.60.21

migrated

I thought I'd try this myself with 1.20.50 now released and it's still there.  I'm pretty sure this issue and MCPE-120618 Custom items are rendered too large in third person view - Jira (mojang.com) are the same bug as the issue seems to only apply to items with a format version of about 1.16.100 or higher.  Thing is, none of the affected items listed in the description have publicly available json configuration from what I can see.

That is until now.  As of 1.20.50 the Apple item was updated to format 1.20.50 (see bedrock-samples/behavior_pack/items/apple.json at main · Mojang/bedrock-samples · GitHub), and as of this update at least (I haven't checked older), it is also affected by this bug:

[media]

I had hoped that if there was at least one official item with a more recent format version that I could see how to fix custom items that use features that have more recently been available in newer versions without forcing me to also use 16x16 resolution textures.  Sadly, the update to the apple has confirmed that apparently not even vanilla items can be correctly configured to work with both a recent item format version and any texter pack with a higher resolution than 16x16.

migrated

also Apple, and Trialkey is affected by this issue.

migrated

affects 1.20.60.22 preview.

migrated

affects 1.20.60.23 preview

migrated

affects 1.20.60.25 Preview


Reply from @unknown:
Please use the Mojira Discord to request adding Affects Versions. Comments like this add unnecessary clutter and hide more important information.
(Delete this entire comment after reading)

angel96444

affects 1.20.80.20 Preview

AgentMindStorm2

This affected items list contains the exact same items as MCPE-172710

Auldrick

The list of affected items in the description is the same as the list of affected items in MCPE-172710. This is probably significant, though it's not obvious what the connection might be. It might also be a coincidence.

JervieA20

Note that for wolf armor was added in latest release (1.20.80) which are no longer experimental outside of gameplay

HARYAMC_

Cobweb is also affected but differently

 

[media]
Invisible826

@unknown, that is MCPE-183464.

AgentMindStorm2

The same items in this list are also affected by MCPE-185729.

HARYAMC_

Died Bundles too

JustenDouma

related to MCPE-169764 ?

KrzysztofPikes

Issue persists in 1.21.41, it's been a full year and a half, making tons of purchasable marketplace content work miserably.

Incyada

If I have to guess what happened, they messed up items texture scaling for items that used a format version of above 1.16.100. Not only that, their first person animations are broken

Studio ZYN

还有一天这个bug就两周年了(

X1Crafts

Does this issue still affect 1.21.80 or the most recent preview?

ZCYF

(Unassigned)

1018032

Confirmed

Multiple

All

item

1.20.40.20 Preview, 1.20.10.21 Preview, 1.20.0.21 Preview, 1.20.0, 1.20.1 Hotfix, ..., 1.21.30, 1.21.31 Hotfix, 1.21.44 Hotfix, 1.21.51 Hotfix, 1.21.80

Retrieved