[MCPE-54853] Eating doesn't always fill hunger but food is consumed

Eating food on a realm (when laggy) food is consumed but there is so much delay in the hunger bar being filled that you are able to eat again before the bar registers.

Also, if the bar registers as full you are able to eat again.

Example:
Player down to 3 hunger points.
Eats steak -> Hunger bar does not increase
Eats another steak -> Hunger bar increases by 3
Eats steak again -> Hunger bar does not increase
Eats another steak -> Hunger bar increases by 3
Eats steak again -> Hunger bar does not increase
Eats another steak -> Whilst mid eating hunger bar is full yet eating continues.

Costs 6 steak to replace hunger bar instead of 3!

Linked issues

is duplicated by

BDS-4213 Can’t Eat Carrots or Potatoes

BDS-6002 Hunger bar bug

MCPE-65587 Cannot eat Carrots or Potatoes (raw)

MCPE-65953 Food Consumption

MCPE-111794 Food not refilling hunger bar.

MCPE-174374 Bug when eating chorus fruit

relates to

MCPE-55263 Hunger Bar not filling when eat and food does not decrease

MCPE-138108 Unable to mine/break in survival mode

Comments

migrated 2019-10-31T19:57:25Z

I've experienced this issue on Android

migrated 2019-10-31T21:20:00Z

have also experienced this issue

migrated 2019-11-03T04:16:46Z

This happens to me on dedicated servers and single player as well. it happens with different types of food including steak golden carrots and golden apples as well.

migrated 2019-11-03T20:53:32Z

I have also had this issue and now bring around 2 different types of food to make it even remotely register, it still occurs even with different foods. I'm on Nintendo Switch and the realm I take part in is assorted Bedrock players.

migrated 2019-11-04T17:51:32Z

Having this most of the time on Android (multiplayer)

and I don't know if it's on Singleplayer too

ravinmaddhatter 2019-11-07T02:10:08Z

Same on realms. Some times it consumes Food. When walking and at only .5 hunger it seemes eating gets cancelled at the last moment continually some times.

I have video if needed

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay) 2019-11-12T12:22:38Z

If you have a video available of the issue that would be useful!

silentwisperer 2019-11-12T20:29:32Z

Small clip of food not being eaten, for minutes.
https://youtu.be/dplHcXKHbHc?t=129

Also when on realms if you eat and fill up your hunger, it still allows you to eat(waste) one more piece of food. No footage of that since i've been actively trying to not waste food xD

foxynotail 2019-11-14T21:39:54Z

Clip of food issues at 22:34
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a1E61Q2Jii4

migrated 2019-11-19T19:30:07Z

I have this issue too!

[Mod] Umija5895M 2019-12-28T15:31:08Z

Still happened in 1.14.1 on Realm. My hunger bar was only down a tiny bit and when I tried to eat it did not fill up, nor did it consume the food, I just got the eating sound and animation. I was able to eat a few minutes later after the hunger dropped a bit more.

PikaBlu 2020-03-13T03:55:39Z

iPad Pro 12.9” Gen 1 on iPadOS 13.4 with Minecraft 1.14.30.

Apparently these are the same issue even though they are not at all the same.

When eating food sometimes when I finish eating and have a full hunger bar it continues to eat, going through the full eating animation yet not consuming the food at the end of it. This isn’t huge but is definitely irritating. I’m not on realms and have no lag when this happens. This issue is the same as many of the tickets labeled here as duplicates but has absolutely nothing to do with this ticket I’m posting on. Hopefully the mods learn to read and fix this, but until then I’ll post updates regarding this issue I’m having here.

GoldenHelmet 2020-03-13T07:52:00Z

@Amphy2k which report are you referring to? I thought I saw it earlier but now can't find.

I agree with you that there are two different bugs being confused here. This report is about realm lag causing food to be consumed without raising the hunger bar. The bug that you describe seems to be a remnant of MCPE-1022; it has nothing to do with lag and can be reproduced simply by walking while eating when health is full.

PikaBlu 2020-03-15T22:36:25Z

@[Helper] GoldenHelmet

I found a new report that describes what I was referring to. MCPE-60807
That is the exact issue I was describing. I couldn’t find it when searching last time, and nobody on the Mojira Discord found it either, but I searched again and found it today.

This bug and that bug are definitely not the same, and should absolutely not be confused for each other, they can be labeled as related though.

Btw MCPE-58113, MCPE-55350, MCPE-58336, MCPE-63531, MCPE-64019. Are all labeled as duplicates of this issue but that is not true. None of them describe this issue. They are all describing the issue I am having in the MCPE-60807 report. So those should all be removed from here and transferred over to there as duplicates of that issue instead. Again they are two completely separate issues. As I said in my comment above, this is a absolutely gargantuan error the mods of this tracker have made. These are two separate issues. Hopefully this can be rectified and both bugs can be properly addressed instead of one being swept under the rug and falsely claimed as a duplicate of a completely different issue.

migrated 2020-03-27T02:00:31Z

Affects 1.16.0.53.

migrated 2020-03-27T02:01:23Z

This issue seems to happen more often when there are two or more players hungry at once.

GoldenHelmet 2020-03-27T13:46:13Z

It certainly occurs more when the network or host cpu is more busy, and I’m sure 2 players eating at once results in that.

I’ve experienced this bug in non-realms 2-player cross-platform when I was on PC and the world was hosted by a Nintendo Switch.