When placing a second slab on one slab, to create a double slab block, the wrong sound event from the block sound type is called in sounds.json. The game is supposed to call the place event, but it calls the item.use.on event instead. This bug is the partial cause of MCPE-155381.
This causes a noticeable difference in placement sounds for some blocks:
[media]This interferes with the intended purpose of the item.use.on event: item interactions, like stripping wood, tilling dirt, and flattening a path. Since these sounds overlap, any resource pack which changes a block interaction sound ends up changing the second slab placing sound too.
Steps to reproduce:
Download and apply the attached sample resource pack:
Strip a log.
Notice the slime sound used to differentiate the item.use.on event.
Place an oak slab.
Notice the normal wood place sound.
Place a second oak slab on top of the first to create a double oak slab.
Notice the slime sound instead of the wood place sound.
Expected result:
Placing a second slab on a single slab plays the same sound as placing the slab anywhere else.
Observed result:
Placing a second slab on a single slab plays the item use sound instead of the place sound.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 9
MCPE-175028
When in a Cherry Grove, placing any wooden slab on another wooden slab makes the 'Cherry wood placing' sound instead of the actual wood sound
Resolved
MCPE-187972
Placing a second slab on a single slab plays item.use.on sound instead of place sound
Resolved
MCPE-219718
Connecting wood slabs plays the wrong sound
Resolved
MCPE-219900
pale oak slab makes the wrong sound
Resolved
MCPE-220945
Incorrect sound of placing a half-block on a half-block
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 8
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response
Is this still an issue in the latest version?
If it is, please be sure to include steps to reproduce the problem:
Steps to Reproduce:
1.
2.
3.Observed Results:
(Briefly describe what happens)Expected Results:
(Briefly describe what should happen)
If your ticket does not look like the example given here, then it's likely to be closed as incomplete.
This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki
Here is a much more detailed version of the report with the root cause identified:
When placing a second slab on one slab, to create a double slab block, the wrong sound event from the block sound type is called in sounds.json. The game is supposed to call the place event, but it calls the item.use.on event instead. This bug is the partial cause of MCPE-155381.
This causes a noticeable difference in placement sounds for some blocks:
[media]This interferes with the intended purpose of the item.use.on event: item interactions, like stripping wood, tilling dirt, and flattening a path. Since these sounds overlap, any resource pack which changes a block interaction sound ends up changing the second slab placing sound too.
To Reproduce
Download and apply the attached sample resource pack:
Strip a log.
Notice the slime sound used to differentiate the item.use.on event.
Place an oak slab.
Notice the normal wood place sound.
Place a second oak slab on top of the first to create a double oak slab.
Notice the slime sound instead of the wood place sound.
Expected Result
Placing a second slab on a single slab plays the same sound as placing the slab anywhere else.
Observed Result
Placing a second slab on a single slab plays the item use sound instead of the place sound.
More noticeable with wooden slabs.