Updated descripton by @unknown
Steps to reproduce
Set a repeating command block with the command /setblock X Y Z <block> destroy
Set up a sticky piston attached to a clock circuit so that it repeatedly pulls away then pushes back the the blocks that are set.
Expected results
Each time the block is destroyed by commands, it drops that block and you see particles for that block.
Actual results
Sometimes the block does not drop, and you see update block particles.
Demo using above steps
Original description
Moving blocks do not drop items when broken by withers or commands. The easiest way to reproduce this bug is to set a repeating command block with the command /fill (x y z)(x y z) air 0 destroy, and then you push blocks with pistons within the region of the fill command.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 7
MCPE-186654
Blocks being pushed by pistons when destroyed by TNT explosion drop nothing
Resolved
MCPE-180388
Block 36
Resolved
MCPE-180325
Moving blocks destroyed by TNT don't drop items
Resolved
MCPE-141188
Breaking a block of which being pushed by piston result in Update block texture
Resolved
MCPE-226813
Moving blocks don't drop items when blown up
Resolved
Attachments
Comments 15
Sorry about that, I will provide a video as soon as I can, I also understand that I should do a better job explaining the bug and reproduction steps of the bug. Also, while I was writing the bug report I actually meant that when you push blocks into the region of the fill command, the block doesn't drop any item, I am truly sorry for the confusion.
When you add the "destroy" part of the command it is supposed to drop the item of the replaced block, normally it does this, but with moving blocks it doesn't.
Hi, could get ownership of this ticket because will can update if happens aswell in the nintendo swich.
I have a different setup with TNT that has the same result, just wanted to bring attention to the fact that It also affects survival. It has been established that it is intended that moving blocks have a blast resistance of 0, witch is beneficial for blast chambers in survival, minimizing the use of TNT, but since moving blocks don't drop, it is pointless to use this mechanic
Much the same as MCPE-84280 can you please clarify what you mean and how you are coming to the conclusion.
A video of the issue may help us identify the bug you are reporting. Based off the description I'm a little lost.
Your repro descriptions would seem to demonstrate that breaking a block immediately on placing doesn't drop the block rather than the block being moving.