[MC-197355] Built-in resource packs (vanilla, programmer art) are incompatible

The bug

Vanilla resource pack shows as "Made for a newer version of Minecraft" in the resource pack menu

How to reproduce

Open 1.16.1
Go to the resource pack menu
=> See the integrated resource pack be "Incompatible".

Attachments

Comments 16

galaxy_2alex 2020-08-07T16:34:41Z

Seems like the pack version of the internal textures was updated to "6" even for 1.16.1, even though 1.16.1 is still on "5".

DrownedZombie 2020-08-08T04:01:44Z

Not sure if this is related to this issue, but it seems that the piglin brute sounds can be played with the playsound command in 1.16.1.

MMK21 2020-08-08T06:24:29Z

Cannot reproduce in 1.16 rc1. Is there something I'm doing wrong?

Cathy 2020-08-08T08:04:53Z

But the pack format in 1.16.1.jar/pack.meta is still 5

[media]

Ranlajetech 2020-08-08T08:20:42Z

How can I reproduce this?

6 more comments

MMK21 2020-08-08T09:06:30Z

@Caden Joy Could you add reproduction steps?

violine1101 2020-08-08T09:08:50Z

I'm only able to reproduce this in 1.16.1, but not in 1.16.1-rc1.

galaxy_2alex 2020-08-08T12:13:26Z

Correct, this only affects 1.16.1, not 1.16.2-rc1.

MartyMacGyver 2020-08-09T01:32:18Z

So I've been using the 1.16.1 line without even knowing this was happening, right through 1.16.2 pre 3. Indeed, in pre 3 I now see the default claims to be "incompatible" as this ticket presents.

But issue MC-197396 is what led me here, because suddenly in 1.16.2 rc 1 all the "Available" resource packs are "incompatible" and are deselected, but you can't even make out which is which thanks to the overlaid warning text.

First, why did the default format version change during a minor bugfix release?

Second, if this is going to be the default version now, despite the fact that old packs still clearly work to a large extent (again, I've been running just fine not even knowing this change even occurred), at least make the pack name legible instead of totally obscuring it in the chooser.

violine1101 2020-08-09T10:34:25Z

at least make the pack name legible instead of totally obscuring it in the chooser.

That's an unrelated issue, I made a separate bug report for that: MC-197512

Jason Neelands 2020-08-09T14:27:20Z

When are we going to see this issue corrected?

If you play java realms this is the only version you can use.

The fallback mode looks terrible.

MMK21 2020-08-09T15:09:38Z

@Jason This bug has been fixed in 1.16.2 rc1. 1.16.2 is set to release next week, and should contain the fix.

SunCat 2020-08-09T16:26:32Z

it has appeared with addition of 1.16.2 rc1, so no, it's not fixed

Jake Remmert 2020-08-09T22:09:26Z

good to know i'm not alone here--i was extremely frustrated when the issue persisted after reinstalling all of Minecraft twice. i'd like to echo Marty's question: why on Earth has the pack format been changed for a minor update? we typically see pack formats last through several major updates, this is very out of place and annoying for creators.

MartyMacGyver 2020-08-10T01:11:27Z

Given the pack version changed (however unexpectedly), my question now is where does one find details about the differences between version 6 and version 5?

slicedlime 2020-08-10T07:13:59Z

Since this will not affect 1.16.2 when it releases, we will leave it as it is - the assets still work correctly, they only show up incorrectly in the menu.