This report is for the old villages before the 1.14 snapshots. See MC-140727 for the same bug with the new 1.14(+) villages.
The bug
Grass can generate inside a villager house. That doesn't seem right.
How to reproduce
This can be in general seen pretty good with a Superflat world filled with water:
minecraft:stone,90*minecraft:water;minecraft:plains;villageSeed: 888005577202285872
/tp @s 629 65 245604 70 10Seed: -5502958542695102104 (amplified terrain generation)
/tp @s -2890 88 1220 90 10Affected village parts
might be incomplete
Large L-shaped house
Row in room, see for example
1 × 6 line below top of roof
Small 4 × 4 house without door
Blocks in entrance
Well
Blocks between roof and well
Lanterns (torches on wool)
Only 2 × 3 area instead of 3 × 3 filled with air
Church
Blocks next to torches in bottom floor
4 × 5 house
Possibly too many blocks replaced with air:
Blocks on roof are replaced in L-shape instead of all or none
Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-50892
Villager houses spawning adjacent to hill will spawn at the correct height but will contain dirt or grass blocks
MC-72485
Sand spawns indoors at desert/plain border
MC-73880
Blocks get generated inside village house
MC-93918
Cactus generating in Village Doorway
MC-109342
Big dirt walls in Large village house.
MC-109422
Village Structures generate with blocks inside and inside mountains
Attachments
Comments
migrated
kumasasa
Please provide the seed of the world (type /seed) and the coordinates (press F3) of that hut.
Sorry, I don't know the seed right now, but I'll find it
I couldn't find it, but a fix (for Mojang) could be to flatten terrain if there's gravel, since their path's are. But then again, if there's gravel in a mountain, looking for a pit in it could help, which it shouldn't. It's just a simple fix I thought of out of random, so I guess I'll wait until this bug gets assigned.
Ezekiel
Joshua type /seed in-game.
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
See MC-23829, I'm just saving time and I would have to write the exact same thing here if I wanted to. What I meant by (in the sentence) I couldn't find IT, I meant the world. I must've deleted, very sorry. If we could find any one else with the same issue, we may have some luck at solving this. Or, not that this HAS to be done, Mojang could try my idea. I'm not sure if they could, but it's just my idea and I don't know much about it.
(My idea above that is. I forgot to specify my idea)
I found another seed with the same thing: -454 78 -752 in -786688341. This may help
Ezekiel
Confirmed.
Thanks!
galaxy_2alex
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases. If this has been done, we can reopen the issue.
Keep in mind that the "Resolved"-Status on this ticket just means "Answered", and that we are waiting for further information on whether this issue still exists or not. We will reopen it as soon as the requested information has been deliviered.
No response for over a year.
[Mod] Neko
Can be reopened MC-106749
Confirmed in 16w43a
Confirmed in 16w44a
Confirmed in 1.11-pre1
Confirmed in 1.11
Confirmed in 16w50a
Confirmed in 1.11.2
Want to suggest another place where terrain will spawn, in this case, the back yard of, I think the butcher. Grass spawns there, as well as in this case, a tree!
marcono1234
@@unknown MC-112446 which is marked as duplicate of this report describes the same, but I feel like that is a different bug because it looks like the trees are placed after the village houses have been placed which might be intended then.
I've seen many times where grass has spawned in a house with a dirt floor, but this time I found grass spawned inside a house with a wooden floor. Pretty sure that shouldn't even be possible. (pic above)
version: 18w14b
seed: -8300275442758179407
xyz: 596 65 -1959
Affects 18w22c
qwerty23495
Can confirm in 1.13-pre3.
Confirmed for 1.13.1.
muzikbike
Affects some NewVillage structures in 18w49a
gaspoweredpick
Can confirm for 18w50a. I have attached a screenshot of a "basement" filled with dirt. (Seed: 3800899156691307234 Coordinates: -799 70 -1299)
gaspoweredpick
Can confirm for 19w03c
Yellow01
This report should probably be closed; MC-140727 was reopened for 1.14+ "New" villages, and old Villages no longer exist in Minecraft.
marcono1234
I have changed MC-140727 to be a clone of this report, but for the new 1.14(+) villages exclusively. This report here (MC-23830) will now only be for the pre 1.14 villages and is therefore now "Invalid" because those villages do not exist anymore.
Please watch (and vote for) MC-140727 if you are interested in this bug being fixed for the new villages.