mojira.dev
MC-46667

Light Level in F3 not correct on slabs, stairs, farmland, and grass path

When standing on a bottom slab (i.e. not a full block) the light level on the F3 screen will be 0 (0 sky, 0 block) even when standing next to a block. This also applies to the bottom step of the stairs.

As far as I know only slabs and stairs have this problem. Daylight sensors, chests, repeaters don't seem to be affected, but I haven't tested this extensively.

Related issues

MC-4257 Half fireworks bug MC-47275 Block light is zero on any slab MC-50102 Light Levels on Half Blocks MC-53450 Stairs give light level 0 MC-54719 Light level 0 in stairs and slabs MC-59558 Light levels are not showing properly MC-60399 0 Block Light on All Step Block Cut Out Portion MC-62489 When standing on a half slab, the light level always shows "0" MC-67268 Light Level is always 0 when on Soul Sand MC-69102 Light level on lower-half slab is 0 MC-75132 No light level at Half Slab MC-82132 Light problem MC-89596 Light level reported as 0, but torches are close by. MC-97032 0 light level on bottom level slabs MC-97804 Stairs lighting issue MC-98820 Light level displays 0 when on path block MC-100818 Stair, Slab, Soulsand, and Path Block F3 Lighting Glitch MC-102486 Dirt Path | Light Level 0 MC-102652 Light level on half-blocks (Slabs) MC-105542 Once you till dirt, the light level goes to 0. MC-105639 The F3 debug info problem about light MC-105677 Light level of 0 on farmland MC-106245 Light level 0 if on a half slab that is on the lower half of the block MC-108537 Farmland and Dirt Pathway Light Levels are 0. MC-108621 Lighting Issues With Grass Path MC-109040 Light level MC-114746 Farmland not showing light value in F3 overlay MC-118769 Light level on slabs MC-119037 No light on farm [Vanilla 1.12] MC-120199 debug screen reports light level as (0 sky, 0 block) MC-120203 Torches do not increase light level for tilled dirt blocks MC-127992 Light level 0 on slabs MC-129005 Can't see light level for plowed blocks MC-133040 Light 0 on paths, farmlands, slab and stairs MC-133578 Jack o lanterns not always registering as light MC-133865 Light 0 on farmland MC-134579 The light value is 0 when on top of a stair block MC-136005 Light in F3 on half slabs (bottom) always 0 MC-137002 Light level shows as 0 when on path MC-138629 no light levals when on a path block MCL-4257 In F3, light level shows 0 while on slabs/stairs.

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media]
kumasasa

Confirmed.

migrated

14w11b still has this issue, if I can, I'll attach my screenshot. I'm even standing next to a glowstone block!

Edit: Screenshot added.

migrated

Still an issue in 14w28b

migrated

Still an issue 14w30b

migrated

still in 14w30c

migrated

Also in 1.8-pre1

migrated

Confirmed for 1.8,

Attatched screenshot.

migrated

And 1.8.1

migrated

Also in 1.8.3

migrated

This bug appears to apply to the lower step of stair blocks as well.

migrated

Can anyone confirm whether this affects mob spawns?

migrated

Mobs do not spawn on half slabs or stairs.

migrated

Bottom stair/bottom slab light of 0 confirmed for 1.8.7.

migrated

Can also confirm for 1.8.7....

migrated

Affects 15w31a

migrated

Confirmed in Minecraft 1.8.8

migrated

Also affects path blocks

migrated

I'm closing this as working as intended: When you are standing on stairs/slabs like this, you are inside the 1x1x1 block boundary. Light level inside blocks is 0, so it should display 0.

Krimsar

What about the aforementioned path blocks though? Also, the light level on carpet, snow or a bed is just fine. Beds, slabs and carpets all behave the same when you place another block on top of them. Is there a significant difference other than the (visual) height?

migrated

The blocks you listed do not block light. Path blocks are solid, but not full height.

migrated

This also happens on farmland, which is actually a problem, because light level affects how crops grow.

kumasasa

There is no problem for farmland. This ticket is about the displayed light level on the debug screen (which is in fact zero when the player is inside blocks) but the actual light level internally used by the game for crops, spawning mobs etc. is correct.

migrated

Yes, I understand the mechanics of what's going on. The farmland is slightly shorter than a full block, putting the bottom of the player's feet in the farmland block, so the debug screen is showing the light level of the farmland block (an opaque block at light level zero), and not the light level of the crop block.

While this effect is rather benign for grass paths, light levels when walking on farmland is not. Light level affects crop growth, and not being able to read that from the debug screen poses a game play problem.

migrated

The debug screen is not meant to be used for gameplay.

muzikbike

This bug has been fixed in 18w46a.

pokechu22

Fixed for everything other than soulsand; I've created MC-139631 for that since soulsand is a bit of a weird case.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

f3, light, slab

Minecraft 14w05a, Minecraft 14w08a, Minecraft 14w11b, Minecraft 14w27b, Minecraft 14w28b, ..., Minecraft 1.8.5, Minecraft 1.8.6, Minecraft 1.8.7, Minecraft 1.8.8, Minecraft 15w31a

Minecraft 18w46a

Retrieved