The bug
Some full blocks cause water to show flowing animation at the sides when placed underwater.
Affected blocks:
Barrier
Beacon
Cauldron
Cauldron (lava filled)
Cauldron (snow filled)
Cauldron (water filled)
End gateway
Shulker box
Monster spawner
Trial spawner
Vault
Frosted ice(fixed in 1.16-pre1)Glass block(fixed)Honey block(fixed in 1.16-pre1)Ice(fixed in 1.16-pre1)Leaves(fixed)Respawn anchor(fixed in 1.16-pre1)Slime block(fixed in 1.16-pre1)Stained glass(fixed)
Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-34968
Water flow texture behaves inconsistently on transparent blocks
MC-50192
Back-side of corner-stairs underwater displays "water edge" air pocket effect
MC-92932
The bug of the water and the crystals that was corrected, not working on the Beacons.
MC-93312
Stationary water shows flowing animation at the sides of barrier blocks
MC-97571
Water floating
MC-99637
Cauldrons still show Water Texture while Underwater
MC-99999
shaved dirt block underwater waterflow bug
MC-119062
farm block displace
MC-123597
Water doesn't connect with farmland
MC-126872
Shulker Box sides are strange underwater
MC-128675
Non waterlogged slabs have water textures on the side
MC-130348
Barrier blocks placed underwater have flowing water texture on the sides
MC-154404
Interaction between blocks and water (Beacons)
MC-183280
Water side texture flowing next to ice
MC-222966
Barrier block visual bug
relates to
MC-91333
Stationary lava shows flowing animation at the sides of some blocks
MC-29257
Flowing water effect at farmland adjacent to water
MC-127005
Bottom of waterlogged blocks shows water texture
MC-56603
Flowing water effect when water is side by side with full block of 8 snow_layer
MC-125351
Some partial blocks that don't pop off when underwater, cause water to show flowing animation at the sides
Attachments
Comments
migrated
migrated
WAI. MC-29257
[Mod]Les3awe
Farmland is a non-complete block.
Can not be applied to this issue.
[Mod]Les3awe
The only common denominator is that they belong to a transparent block.
But the glass been fixed.
migrated
Look at the screenshots in MC-29257...
migrated
Yes, but still it was fixed for glass, so unless mojang resolves this themselfs, you can't say this is intended as it got fixed with another block, with the same issue
Irbis
Also affected are farmland and grass_path Should it be added here or in new report?
migrated
That's MC-29257 since they are about the same block
migrated
Stairs with water is linked to here, but it's not mentioned in the description, same for snow layer 8
[Mod]Les3awe
Someone can confirm it?
migrated
It's nice that this got fixed for glass, but I would've liked this to be changed for ice and beacons too. But I guess you can't have everthing.
ziggurism
Are we sure that this is WAI, since the same issue was recently fixed for glass? MC-35790
migrated
@unknown marked this as intended, not a modderator
muzikbike
Why, exactly, is this WAI? Surely this should be considered a bug if it were fixed for glass.
Anyways, on the Pocket Edition, I can confirm that this "bug" affects both pistons and the backs of stairs, whilst slime blocks have this weird texture bug. Ice is unaffected as it is opaque, another seemingly works as intended feature.
muzikbike
Relates to MCPE-11140 and MCPE-11141
migrated
If this "works as intended" for many blocks (e.g., farmland, beacons which are inconsistent with dirt and glass, respectively) then I strongly encourage you to change your intentions because they make no logical sense. What the gamer cares about is the end result, not the poor implmentation decisions. (I'm sorry if this sounds passive-aggressive, I don't mean it like that at all; just trying to give what I think is good feedback.)
muzikbike
No longer affects farmland, grass paths, the backs of stairs, or pistons.
Jack McKalling
After an internal discussion, we've decided to split this report into three categories of blocks:
Full blocks
Non-full blocks that are washed away by water or pop off (now maintained in MC-204842)
Non-full blocks that can be placed underwater (now maintained in MC-125351)
This report is dedicated to only the first category of blocks (at least from now on). I also took the liberty to clarify the description and summary of all three tickets. Hopefully this will clarify what block goes where.
If you find a block that should be listed here but isn't in any of the three yet, you're welcome to comment.
migrated
Structure void isn't a full block
Jack McKalling
Thanks, moved.
Avoma
Can confirm in 21w05b.
Avoma
Can confirm in 21w13a.
migrated
Can confirm in 1.17-pre1.
migrated
Can confirm in 1.17.1. Also applies to tinted glass
Jack McKalling
@unknown That is not the same issue with tinted glass. What you're seeing is the colour of water on the other side of the block. Water does not show the flowing water animation on the sides of tinted glass.
migrated
@Jack McKalling Sorry, my mistake. I hadn't realised, but I was running a rendering mod which changed that. Thanks for clearing up 🙂
Avoma
Can confirm in 1.18.1.
Avoma
Can confirm in 1.18.2.
migrated
In 22w15a
AMGAMES04
Can confirm in 23w45a
[Mod] Jingy
Affects the recently addd trial spawner and vault blocks, just like the spawner.
muzikbike
Cauldrons aren't full cubes with full side faces, so shouldn't they be excluded?
[Mod]Les3awe