The breaking animation when breaking blocks in Survival mode is too dark. In both Bedrock and Java editions, the destroy_stage texture files are identical, yet it still appears darker in the Bedrock Edition.
What I expected to happen was...:
The block breaking animation would appear lighter, like how it used it many years ago and how it does on the Java Edition.
What actually happened was...:
Instead, it appeared very dark.
Steps to Reproduce:
Load a world
Switch to Survival mode
Begin breaking a block
Notice how dark the breaking animation appears
Linked issues
is duplicated by 11
MCPE-68158
Destroying block stages looks ugly
Resolved
MCPE-100126
Stair's and Slab's have half different color when broked
Resolved
MCPE-103036
breaking animation is too dark
Resolved
MCPE-104410
Minecraft Bedrock Breaking Block animation is too dark
Resolved
MCPE-108015
Why is the blocks breaking animation in Bedrock Edition is DARKER unlike block breaking animation in Java
Resolved
MCPE-119753
Block breaking animation doesn't properly overlay/integrate with block texture
Resolved
MCPE-131343
Block Breaking Animation is to Dark
Resolved
MCPE-163714
Cracks when mining a block differ from Java and Bedrock
Resolved
MCPE-186630
The Mining Texture is darker compared to Java
Resolved
MCPE-190560
Block Breaking Cracks Are Too Dark/Thick
Resolved
MCPE-190889
Block breaking texture does not match Java Edition
Resolved
Attachments
Comments 30
This is actually a quite an old bug, and the tree particles are incorrect.
Relates to MCPE-34795.
Also there's a bug with breaking slabs and stairs, where the "breaking" animation plays the bock animation and the parts where there isn't anything just becomes a non-physical grey wall
Seems like the blending mode used is wrong, or something similar, because the textures are identical
Why is this still not fixed. It bugs me so much
This bug also affects version 1.15.0.55 beta
Still affects 1.16.0.60 beta
affects 1.16.2 release
Will this get fixed, the current one really does look ugly
Affects 1.16.200.53
affects 1.17.10.23
Still affects 1.16.220 release. Mostly on mobile phones but can sometimes accrue win10 as well.
It's on all platforms running bedrock edition.
affects 1.17.10
Affects 1.17.30.25
Affects 1.17.40.20
Effects 1.18.027
@unknown: Stop making pointless edits to your comment. Every time you edit your comment, an email is sent to everyone watching the ticket.
Affects 1.18.10.20
Should also be present in 1.18.0 full release when that comes out.
Also affects 1.18.12
Affects 1.19.10
Sadly, still an issue.
Darker breaking overlay looks way better than Java Edition one even if it's unintended (which is likely not the case, because it's impossible to accidentally add it, and even if it is unintended it looks much better in that way anyway) I really hope they will keep it like this and maybe even add it to Java Edition, and Bedrock blending makes more sense, according to breaking overlay texture.
Affects 1.20.73
I just realized something, and I believe that Java's breaking overlay is the one that is broken, because on Java breaking overlay render extremely weirdly on translucent blocks such as ice for example, and doesn't render properly on grass block side, same happens on Legacy Console Edition, but doesn't happen on Bedrock, and also the way overlay looks in-game on Java doesn't make sense if you compare it to the texture of it, and Bedrock's one is completely fine and looks really nice, so Java's breaking overlay needs to be changed to match Bedrock instead of changing Bedrock's one, and this bug report should be marked as works as intended.
Can confirm 1.21.60.23.
Still an issue. The MC Bedrock block breaking animation feels so cheap
Still affects 1.21.60.25 preview
The one on Java looks weird, breaking overlay on Bedrock is perfect, it looks like actual cracking and has a bit more transparent shadow below it to simulate depth, while on Java that shadow is brighter than the original block for some reason, which doesn’t make any sense, even in compare to breaking overlay texture itself, also breaking overlay on Java is broken on the ice blocks, and is applied twice on grass block sides, and none of these issues are in Bedrock, in my opinion overlay is broken on Java and not on Bedrock.
Notice how you punch the birch tree on the Bedrock edition it shows the top/bottom breaking textures instead of the bark.