mojira.dev
MC-128690

Water does not flow sideways when there’s no block below it

The bug

Normally when you break the docks in a floating village the water fills in the empty space. In the newest snapshot it's just sitting there. I tried outside the village with newly placed blocks and the same thing happened.

seed: -8300275442758179407

Related issues

MC-128731 Water source/s is/are not coming back MC-128866 Water source blocks do not always create new sources MC-128979 Water - Does not replenish when filling a bucket MC-128990 Water doesn't flow/form sourceblocks properly MC-129042 Water doesn't work properly MC-129054 Naturally generated water does not update! MC-129060 Water not updating correctly MC-129226 Water not flowing correctly MC-129252 Water not creating source blocks MC-129305 The underwater blocks MC-129357 Water does not fill in blocks where blocks were removed in two block deep water pools and oceans MC-129382 Getting water out of the ocean leaves empty block MC-129406 Water glitches in the snapshot 18w19b MC-129478 Water sources and water logged blocks don't attempt to flow sideways if not above certain blocks MC-129635 water not updating corectly when removing blocs MC-129680 Water Does Not Fill Manually On Top of Other Water Blocks MC-129764 Breaking blocks under water sometimes creates air bubbles MC-129828 Whenever I fill a bucket with water or Place a block in the ocean and destroy it the source block does not come back. MC-129899 Torches can be placed underwater when there is a block above them. MC-129966 Unable to create 2 block deep water source (or 'swimming pool') MC-130079 Water doesn't work correctly MC-130198 Water does not fill in when it should / water not flowing MC-130531 Water flow does not come from the water source at the sides, as it was before MC-130656 water bug MC-130939 water on water doesn't flow properly MC-131050 Water Won't Fill Area MC-131073 Water does not flow properly MC-131104 Water dosn't flow on Water MC-131213 Water bucket does not fill with water MC-131376 Placed Water Flows Improperly MC-131418 Water not spreading on top of newly created water layers MC-131518 Water does not flow when placed on top of water MC-131905 Water Not Flowing Properly MC-133602 Infinite water does not fill up every area

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media]
migrated

Can confirm, tried to fill a space with water and noticed it would not spread but stay in that form.

migrated

New water source blocks only generate when solid blocks are directly below. Like in your picture, the water "holes" are only in deep water.

migrated

That’s not the issue here, the issue is that water doesn’t start flowing at all.

migrated

It flows on solid blocks. Just empty a bucket on land. You can create 1 block deep lakes without a problem.

migrated
[media]

Also it appears to have very random behaviors in general, in this attached instance it split into a v instead of spreading like it used to.

migrated

That’s a different issue. (MC-76857)

Irbis

Water source don't flow to the sides when there's falling water/another water source below the source.
Visible when placing water on the ceiling - it will flow to the bottom creating 1-wide waterfall, but don't flow to the sides like before creating cross-shaped waterfall.

migrated

If I pick up water in a bucket that has a water block beneath it, it leaves a hole in the water body - ie the neighbouring water blocks don't flow in to fill it. It works as normal if there is a solid block beneath it.

migrated

Here the water should flow also (tested on 18w19a)

[media]

migrated

Confirming, with image, that issue persists and is repeatable in 18w19a

[media]

migrated

Confirmed in 18w19b

migrated

Confirmed in 18w20a

migrated

Confirmed in 18w20b

migrated

Possible related bug: MC-129899

migrated

Related to this, in 18w20c, if you place water on top of a sign, bottom slab or stair (say at the top of a water elevator or in a water escalator) the water will not run off of the block above the sign, slab or stair (did not test this with other blocks). This makes water elevators and escalators rather useless (aside from the fact that many mobs like skeletons and the various versions of zombies no longer swim up the water elevators).

It does not seem to matter whether there is a block or air next to the sign or stair (note: water flowing to the stair in the image below properly flows up to the water source on top of the stair).

[media]
migrated

Confirmed in 18w21a

Lukeonia1

Not sure if this is related or a separate bug: I noticed in 18w21a, "natural" water source blocks will not spread horizontally more than one block.

"Natural" sources being those generated with the world, or formed by normal source-block-on-two-sides water mechanics. Source blocks from water buckets, or those containing sea grass, waterlogged blocks, etc are not affected and behave normally. I did a little other testing, and found that a single-block source in a cave was unaffected, but water in a subterranean lake was.

 

[media]
migrated

Separate bug.

migrated

Confirmed in 18w21b

migrated

Confrmed n 18w22a

migrated

Confirmed in 18w22b

Nathan Adams

I can't reproduce this in 18w22b.

migrated

@unknown I could reproduce it in both Creative as well as Survival mode by clicking rapidly with empty waterbucket(s), see:

[media]

[media]

Edit: Upon relog, those water holes are gone though, maybe just a visual glitch?

Because I stuck my head into one of those water holes in Survival, bubbles go down as if it were water, as opposed to that bug in previous snapshots:

[media]
migrated

I can still reproduce in 18w22b, make sure there's not a block below the water source.

[media]
migrated

Also reproducable like so:

[media]

migrated

As one of the early bug reporters in this issue, I would like to say that as far as I can see in 18w22c it appears to be fixed in single player. I reproduced the exact same issue and the water filled up the hole. There may be a similar bug thats not resolved, but the one I submitted is. Thanks.

migrated

Okay, so. The initial problem I found where breaking blocks on top of water created a hole has been fixed. This is the pic I posted when I found the problem:

[media]

Now when you break blocks that are sitting on water it fills in as it did previously.

However there is still a bug of some sort messing with the water. I believe it is this bug, which I reported as well: MC-129899

If you place a torch in the water with a block above it the water disappears and the torch stays in an air bubble. If you break the torch the air bubble remains. If you break the block above the bubble the water will fill in.

In addition to this if you have a two block wide body of water and you break one or two blocks at the end the water will not fill in. It doesn't happen when the water is three across and you break all three blocks in a row. It also doesn't happen if you break the center block. But it does happen if you break the end blocks and leave the middle block intact.

[media][media]
migrated

Confirmed in 18w22c

migrated

Affects 1.13 pre-release 1
I was making a water tank and the second or higher layers of water do not automatically fill in like they used to.

migrated

Confirmed in 1.13 pre-release 2

migrated

I've been observing this for ages already. Always thought it's WAI.

violine1101

This is definitely not WAI.

jonaskill555

It seems that it doesn't occur with colum bubble affected water because that flows normally 

[media]
ZeNico13

The problem is still here in 1.13-pre8.

[media]

migrated

Confirmed in 1.13pre8

[media]
qwerty23495

This issue is already been fixed. We will need More than a dark screenshot to reopen anything.

migrated
[media][media]
boq

Does it stay that way after relogging? If no, it's seems more like MC-12363.

migrated

No but those mountains of water are still there after i relog. I don't know if that is working as intended but it seems really weird.

boq

Well, buffet worlds don't guarantee sane results, especially if you try to do deep-ocean nether.

migrated

This might not be part of the the issue but I sometimes get one block air pockets in water if I keep using the empty bucket on water in creative mode fast enough.

migrated

That's MC-12363 (or a variant of it).
Removed all screenshots that are actually MC-12363. and not this issue.

ZeNico13

Still in 19w08a

[media]
violine1101

That screenshot doesn't describe this issue. If you think this is a new bug, please create a new ticket. Apart from that, unless I am mistaken, this is how water physics work in Minecraft as far as I know.

migrated

boq

Confirmed

Minecraft 18w16a, Minecraft 18w19a, Minecraft 18w19b, Minecraft 18w20a, Minecraft 18w20b, ..., Minecraft 18w22b, Minecraft 18w22c, Minecraft 1.13-pre1, Minecraft 1.13-pre2, Minecraft 1.13-pre3

Minecraft 1.13-pre4

Retrieved