mojira.dev
MC-2034

Brewing stands' input slots do not have normal stacking behavior

The input slots (fuel, ingredient) of a brewing stands behave unlike all other slots, in the following ways:

  • Right-clicking on a stack of items generally splits it in half; but on the input slots of brewing stands, it picks up the entire stack instead. The client still assumes only half a stack was picked up.

  • If I have some of an item in the stand and some in my inventory, shift-clicking the stack in my inventory does not add it to ingredient slot in the brewing stand

Using the new double-click to pick up a stack inventory feature can have some unexpected results. To reproduce:

1. Put a stack of nether wart in the input of a brewing stand.
2. Have a single nether wart in your inventory.
3. Double click the single nether wart. Notice you now have 64 nether wart, even though 65 total have dissapeared from the stand and your inventory.

Neither of these behaviors occur with other specialized input slots, such as a furnace's fuel slot.

Also note other related inventory management issues relating to brewing stands listed in the "relates to" links below.

Linked issues

MC-2634 You can't half your items when right clicking things out of a brewing stand. Resolved MC-10635 Stacks in brewing stands behave incorrectly Resolved MC-26081 Cannot right click to divide stacks in brewing stations Resolved MC-30904 You can't right click items out of the brewing stand ingredient slot Resolved MC-53134 Brewing stand stops brewing if nether warts are right clicked Resolved

Comments 16

I can confirm this. If you have at least 1 nether wart on the top slot of the brewing stand, you can't shit-click more nether wart. If the top slot is empty, shift-click works normally.

Splitting Bug Confirmed. Shift Clicking Not Adding To Existing Stacks But Instead Creating New Stacks Could Just Be A Way Mojang Implemented Protection For Illicitly Stacking Potions.

Confirmed in 1.4.6.

Can confirm in 1.5.1. Was just about to submit a duplicate of this, good thing I remembered to search at the last minute.

Confirmed in 1.6.2. Removed meta-discussion from description.

6 more comments

Still an issue in 1.8.4

Confirmed for 15w43c, does weird stuff when using right-click the second time.

Still can't shift-click if the top slot isn't empty through 16w38a.

Kevin Reid

Erik Broes

Confirmed

GUI, brewing_stand, input, slot, stacking

Minecraft 1.4.2, Minecraft 1.4.3, Minecraft 1.4.6, Minecraft 1.5, Minecraft 1.5.1, ..., Minecraft 1.8.8, Minecraft 15w33b, Minecraft 15w36d, Minecraft 15w42a, Minecraft 15w43c

Minecraft 15w44a

Retrieved