[MC-33015] Breaking / walking over fire block plays wool / carpet sound

When I put water on fire, I hear wool breaking sound.
And I see Fire "Particles".

Linked issues

duplicates 1

MC-171366 Indirect breaking of minecraft:fire or minecraft:soul_fire does not make the "hissing"/"extinguishing" sound Reopened

Attachments

2015-10-05-2207-42.mp4

Comments 38

Player_Char 2013-09-28T06:49:09Z

Confirmed.

galaxy_2alex 2013-09-28T09:44:06Z

Can confirm.
Because technically, the fire block gets broken instead of put out now.

kumasasa 2013-09-28T10:10:58Z

Confirmed.

Bryce Siefert 2013-09-28T20:45:07Z

Confirmed in 1.6.2

Torabi 2013-10-24T17:20:04Z

Related to MC-35034.

28 more comments

Ezekiel 2013-11-29T04:50:03Z

Is this still a concern in the latest Minecraft version 13w48b? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

marcono1234 2014-06-10T16:59:42Z

Confirmed for 14w21b also with dispenser

Please reopen this is definitely not intended!
Floating water also doesn't cause the fire to create the break particles!

Torabi 2014-06-10T17:06:44Z

If you'll look in the ticket history, you can see that @unknown himself marked this as Working As Intended on January 21, 2014. So no, we're not going to contradict him and reopen this.

marcono1234 2014-06-10T17:20:52Z

This make definitely no sense because floating water isn't acting like this but nevermind...

Torabi 2014-06-10T17:37:12Z

It's simply how @unknown decided to fix MC-8220, MC-3737, and many others. Placing water "breaks" the block it replaces, so that it drops them as items if appropriate. This happened with water and lava for a while (See MC-18365), but Grum was able to fix that, so I'll bring this ticket to his attention and see if he wants to revisit this.

marcono1234 2014-06-10T18:59:26Z

Alright thank you 😉

Torabi 2014-06-18T10:46:26Z

@unknown has decided to take another look at this. It's not a high-priority item, so it may take a while to get around to it, but he thinks he should be able to do it.

Joshua Lee 2014-06-18T10:48:48Z

This glitch was discovered months ago

marcono1234 2014-07-18T20:21:12Z

Confirmed for

14w29b
14w30c
14w31a Only the sound part is fixed, the animation is still wrong
Minecraft 1.8-pre 1 Animation still not fixed and now sound indeed like wool placing

DF 2014-07-31T01:20:35Z

Fire breaking sounds like wool now?

Torabi 2014-08-29T07:36:56Z

So the sound was correct in 14w31a? In 1.8-pre3, I don't find the particles very noticeable, but it does still sound like wool.