Mouse wheel scrolling function too sensitive with mouse wheels without distinctive clicks

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 1.8.1 Prerelease 3 or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

It is an hardware issue though, I don't really see a reason to add, maybe even pretty complicated, support for one specific piece of hardware.But in the end, it's not my decision.

I can't update the affected versions as this ticket is marked as resolved.
It is sill an issue, though.

Furthermore, there are a lot more mice (and trackpads) affected by this now. Just search for "mouse touch scroll" on Amazon. Many mice now use a touchpad for scrolling which lacks the clicks many mice use for their wheels. Also there are mice with wheels that lack a distinct click. Using these devices it is also hard to switch to the next item.

This is no longer only an OS X issue!

The solution this ticket asks for is an option to simply ignore the scroll input. Mouse buttons are already configurable. This shouldn't be a hard problem to solve.

Not a Minecraft bug.
Disable scroll and change sensitivity in your OS.

For feature suggestions or changes please see: Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit.

Sorry Kumasasa - you're wrong. This is a bug and it does only affect minecraft. I have never had any other issues with any other apps - in Minecraft the mouse wheel is extremely over-sensitive and cannot be disabled for Minecraft only. I think expecting users to disable their mouse wheel completely in their everyday OS just to play Minecraft is a rather short-sighted suggestion.

This issue is not resolved.

This is a hardware / OS specfic issue, Compare for e.g. MC-15705 MC-538 MC-21211 MC-62994 MC-54194.

As stated earlier, it is an issue effecting a lot of mice. Not just Apple mice and OS X. All mice without distinct clicks on the wheel or a touchpad instead of a wheel are effected. Even Microsoft is producing mice with a touchpad for scrolling.
This is no niche issue!

To disable scrolling in the OS is not a solution.

Sometimes a solution is to adopt to new/changed hardware to make life more convenient for the user.

Yes, still not a Minecraft bug, but still a feature request.

Kumasasa, rather than unhelpfully slapping our wrists for what we've called the issue, is it possible that someone might fix it?

It is somewhat ridiculous to pay for a game and then find that one needs to fundamentally alter the basic way one's operating system works, or must purchase new hardware just to enjoy it. It's even more annoying to report the problem and find that it's merely considered a 'feature request' and not really worth anybody's time, despite the fact that it's only Minecraft that actually does this and despite the fact that it renders the game unplayable.

'Feature request' or not, it seems I'm required to register and mess about on Reddit until I have enough experience to post a about this in what is deemed 'the right place'. What a ridiculous, hoop-jumping state of affairs for a paid-for product. As it stands, it doesn't really look like there's much point in continuing this discussion in any location with the attitude being displayed; probably time to stop watching this issue.

Well ok. Reopened, redefined the summary.

Add a mouse sensitivity slider in the controls maybe?

I would settle for the ability to rebind "next slot" and "previous slot" to be anything other than "mouse wheel up" and "mouse wheel down". Why are these two actions the only ones that I can't reconfigure? Anyone with a reasonably modern mouse is going to be annoyed by this.

@Trejkaz

That would be a nice solution. Those aren't the only non-configurable actions by the way (http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Controls#Non-configurable_controls).

A sensitivity slider would be nice for those of us who do prefer to use the mouse wheel, as well as making it a configurable action for those who do not.

For what it's worth, this issue isn't confined to the Magic Mouse. Every mouse I have used (Apple, Microsoft, and Logitech) has the same issue. Setting the global OS scroll sensitivity to nearly ZERO seems to kinda work, but that is a very inconvenient solution as it renders scrolling useless in every other application on the computer.

This should definitely be considered as a bug, I've never had this problem with other games. If this cannot be fixed, we should be allowed to map these controls differently or at least disable them.

Yes, a sensitivity slider for the mousewheel is badly needed.

Confirmed for all versions until 16w33a.

This only affected me when I updated my OSX this morning to Sierra 10.12.
The trackpad scrolls too fast but the magic mouse works fine.

Changing trackpad settings does not resolve the issue.

Same Max 😛

I have the same thing happen on my MacBook Pro Laptop with the trackpad scrolling. I don't use a mouse. I too noticed only after updating to Mac OSX Sierra.

Im having the same issue. I feel its related to upgrading to sierra. Not sure how one could call it a dupe of a 2015 issue if sierra came out only a week or 2 ago.

It's certainly not related to the macOS Sierra update. I've had this issue since I started using this MacBook Pro and a Magic Mouse in 2012. I eventually got used to it and avoided scrolling with the touchpad and mouse. Occasionally though, I still accidentally scroll when I click and a few of those times I placed a bucket of lava, which killed me and destroyed things.

It actually isn't related to Mac at all. Most mice have a wheel that triggers the scroll event every "click". Other mice such as the Apple Magic Mouse, Microsoft Arc Touch Mouse, etc. trigger the scroll event every time you move the finger the slightest amount.

I've also tested this on Arch Linux (with XFCE). By default, the Magic Mouse scrolling is painfully slow in pretty much every program, but works great in Minecraft. I typed the following commands to set the scrolling sensitivity to a comfortable speed:

sudo rmmod hid_magicmouse
# scroll-speed value from 0 (slow) to 63 (fast):
sudo modprobe hid_magicmouse scroll-speed=40 scroll-acceleration=1

This made scrolling work great in every program except Minecraft. This isn't as much of a problem on Linux since you can easily create a shell script to toggle the scrolling speed. On macOS and Windows, changing the scrolling speed every time you run (and quit) Minecraft is NOT a good solution. A good solution is to implement a scrolling sensitivity slider in the controls menu.

Now it's happening to all my computers after Sierra Update.

I just updated my iMac desktop computer this morning to OSX Sierra.
The problem of scrolling too fast is now on this computer too! So now both my macbook pro and imac have the same issue.
It can not be fixed by adjusting the scrolling speed in Accessibility or turning off inertia while scrolling.
My issue of scrolling too fast is without a doubt related to the update I just did to my operating system.
I never had this issue before with any updates to my Mac computers.

Certainly interesting that Sierra is triggering it so consistently, but there have definitely been instances of this since well before even Yosemite and on mice other than the Magic Mouse (Logitech, Microsoft, and Apple mice for me)

The rest of us have been seeing this forever... so it does sound different on the surface, but maybe it's just two different symptoms for the same problem.

Whilst the issue may be related, I feel like the Sierra one is caused by a different issue than people with it previously.

I have OS X 10.12 and the mouse wheel is very sensitive. It is hard to scroll to the item you want to use in the hot bar. This affects 1.10.2.

@unknown, 1.10.2 is already marked as affected

Hey, this exact problem is happening to me, it has been effecting me in 1.8.9 and 1.11.2.
I am using the M705 Logitech mouse and in the Mac OS X 'Sierra' version.
Hopefully this error will be resolved soon.

This problem has been happening for me for years without a good solution. I have two Logitech mice that it effects (an Anywhere mouse MX and Performance MX), both using the wireless dongle, Logitech unifying software (12.01) and control center (3.95).

I play modded, but it does occur on all client versions up to the most recent snapshot.

I spoke with Logitech and their perspective is if the hardware functions as intended everywhere else, its a software issue.

I am more incline to think its an Apple issue (especially since its seems affected by OS updates), but it would be nice if there was a workaround UI solution from Mojang.

@Seth It isn't just an Apple issue. As I have said before, it also happens with other operating systems.

The driver program detects when you move your finger on the mouse and sends scroll events. When you change the sensitivity, it basically changes how often it sends scroll events. A mouse with a scroll wheel will trigger the event on every "click". I've noticed that some modern scroll wheel mice also have smooth scrolling and don't "click" when you turn the wheel. Apple has likely changed something in the code that handles scrolling, which is why it is happening more consistently in macOS Sierra.

Afaik the reason Minecraft is so sensitive to mice with smooth scrolling is because it is switching hotbar item on every scroll event. Changing the scrolling sensitivity in your mouse settings is not a proper solution. Minecraft should implement a scrolling sensitivity slider. 100% = default (i.e. how it current handles scrolling), 75% = 25% of scroll events are ignored, 50% = half of scroll events are ignored, etc. 0% would completely disable scrolling for the hotbar. As @Trejkaz suggested, being able to rebind the next/previous slot controls is also a nice solution.

An alternative, less ideal solution is to use a program that, when Minecraft is the active application, either:
a) Changes the scrolling sensitivity (only for Minecraft) or
b) Disables scrolling and binds other buttons to scroll up/down e.g. mouse button 4 and 5 (for mice with extra buttons)

For reference, there are years' worth of complaints about this issue here:

http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/support/unmodified-minecraft-client/1859815-minecraft-scrolls-too-fast