Update by @unknown:
Repro Steps:
Place cobblestone into a fuelled furnace (this gets smelted into Stone)
Take the Stone from the furnace output, and try and smelt that again
Observed Results:
The stone obtained from step one cannot be smelted into smooth stone (because it has a damage value of 32767).
Expected Results:
The player should be able to smelt stone into smooth stone without issue.
Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Notes:
Original Description:
Using a furnace, Stone does not cook to Smooth Stone in this version.
I place Stone in the input slot of the furnace, and coal (or other fuel) in the fuel slot, with the result that the progress bar does not move.
I expected Smooth Stone to result from a smelting operation. But instead, no smelting occurs, and no fuel is expended.
I have attached an image that shows what happens when Stone is inserted into a furnace, along with valid fuel.
The Stone in question was obtained by smelting Cobblestone.
Oddly enough, while investigating this further, I found that Stone obtained through Silk Touch does not stack with Stone obtained through smelting Cobblestone!
Related issues
is duplicated by
BDS-1052
Smooth stone
BDS-1055
Stone would not smelt into Smooth Stone
MCPE-47955
Smooth stone in survival is unobtainable.
MCPE-47981
Stone can no longer be smelted into smooth stone
MCPE-47994
Stone can't be melted into smooth stone
MCPE-48049
There is no way to make a smooth stone.
MCPE-48148
Stones are unmeltable
MCPE-48202
Smooth stone
MCPE-48234
You can't smelt stone on furnace
MCPE-48242
I cannot smelt stine to turn it into blast furnace
MCPE-48266
Stone Not Smelting
MCPE-48274
stone cannot smelt to smooth stone
MCPE-48309
I can't smelt smoothstone
MCPE-48315
Can't Smelt Stone To Smooth Stone On 1.13 Beta
MCPE-48416
Stone
MCPE-48436
Stone becoming nonstackable with other stone.
MCPE-48516
Из камня не получается гладкий камень
MCPE-48529
The stone cannot be melted
MCPE-48698
Stone blocks not smelting into Smooth Stone blocks in furnace
MCPE-48722
Furnace is not smelting to smooth stone
MCPE-48751
i cant smelt up stone to make smooth stone.. i dont know if its a bug or there's a new way of obtaining smooth stone but i hope this issue gets fix next update cuz.. i need my smooth stone mojang
MCPE-48759
Smooth stone won't smelt
MCPE-48794
Block issue -stone -smealting Error
MCPE-48836
Crafting issue
MCPE-48843
Stone not smelting to smooth stone
MCPE-48864
smooth stone
MCPE-48917
Stone in furnace doesn't give smooth stone
MCPE-48920
When trying to get Smooth Stone it is impossible to get it through a furnace unless you use silk touch. It won't work if you smelt cobblestone and then try to smelt stone.
MCPE-48951
Smooth Stone Smelting Not Working
MCPE-49099
Can't smelt stone into smooth stone
MCPE-49207
Can't Smelt Stone Into Smooth Stone In Survival
MCPE-49321
Smelting
MCPE-49397
I can't make Smooth Stone
MCPE-49400
Bug with the creation of a smooth stone
MCPE-49451
stone
MCPE-49491
Smelting stone to smooth stone
MCPE-49597
Stone won't get smelted into smooth stone
MCPE-49716
Cant smelt stone into smooth stone
MCPE-49897
Cannot convert stone to smooth stone in furnace
MCPE-49998
Smelting Smooth Stone Bug
MCPE-56167
Smelted Stone from Hopper-Furnace cannot be smelted into Smooth Stone in any furnace
relates to
Attachments
Comments
migrated
migrated
I was not able to duplicate, did you get the stone from silk touch? Or did you smelt the cobblestone? More details like this is appreciated. Thank you for listening! 🙂
migrated
The Stone was smelted from Cobblestone blocks.
migrated
@Mega_Spud this seems to be a common theme with smokers, furnaces, and blast furnaces. If you check out MCPE-47684 you can see a similar issue. Just wanted to bring it to your attention! 🙂
DrageonDB
Android is work, but win10 is not work smelting stone to smooth stone
[media]
migrated
I was able to duplicate this issue on Xbox One on 2 separate worlds. It renders the blast furnace uncraftable.
migrated
According to MCPE-48342 coal is also affected by this furnace bug.
migrated
This same bug is happening to be across all all seeds on Xbox.
migrated
Same problem on Win10
migrated
I'm having this issue as well on Xbox & Windows 10 on a Realm. I didn't realize it until my sorting system kept sending stone past my stone filter.
migrated
Issue happening on Nintendo Switch
migrated
"Oddly enough, while investigating this further, I found that Stone obtained through Silk Touch does not stack with Stone obtained through smelting Cobblestone!"
Does that mean Silk Touch stone can be smelted or does that still not work? It's such a pain not being able to get a blast furnace on my survival world.
[Mod] LateLag
Yes Jacob, you're correct. If you place the smelted blocks on the ground and mine them with silk touch, you'll get properly working stone. Then you'll be able to smelt it and craft the blast furnace.
[Mod] LateLag
Based on other tickets and comments, it seems that 1.12 full release is also affected, can anyone else confirm?
[Mod] OcelotOnesie
1.12.0 isn't affected.
[Mod] LateLag
Are you sure? naec4 even said that Nintendo Switch is affected. Also, I saw your comment on MCPE-46812 (which is basically the same issue, with the same cause) saying that 1.12.0 is affected.
[Mod] OcelotOnesie
Yes, I tested it before making the comment.
migrated
I play on switch and I do not have this problem
[Mod] LateLag
Fixed in 1.13.0.4 beta, but I'm not sure if it fixes existing bugged blocks.
migrated
Tested today on Xbox One with 1.13.0.4 and new stone blocks worked as expected but existing bugged blocks would not smelt.
migrated
[Bedrock Win10 Single Player & BDS] Stone which is obtained with Silk Touch will not stack with cobble that was smelted into stone. Stone via Silk Touch is given a Damage value of 0, while cobble smelted into stone is given a Damage value of 32767. I didn't experience problems with smelting either into smooth stone, only stacking in inventory & chests. I did not make a separate ticket since it is possible the Damage value is causing the problems.
[media]
[Mod] Celesian
Stone blocks prior to 1.13 will be still affected, so we are tracking that as a separate ticket MCPE-54617