mojira.dev
MC-216737

When replacing tuff, ores still generate with a "stone" background below y=0

The preferred solution for this issue would be to have specific tuff versions of ores.

When replacing tuff, ores generate with a stone background instead of the characteristic deepslate that is intended of this y region. This is due to tuff being in the wrong block tag. Tuff appears to sometimes be replaced with proper deepslate ores, but this is rare (one example attached) and is probably caused by actual deepslate coincidentally being in that position..

This could be cheaply fixed by simply making that which replaces tuff be deepslate instead, but a preferable, much more elegant solution would instead be to add tuff versions of ores.

Linked issues

MC-216750 Regular diamond ore generates below y=0 Resolved MC-216763 Deepslate gold doesn't spawn when it is inside tuff Resolved MC-216772 Normal Ores generating below y 0 Resolved MC-216775 deepslate ores dont generate as deepslate Resolved MC-216780 I deleted this Resolved

Attachments

Comments 17

Direct proof that tuff is indeed the problem:

[media]

The color of the stone ores is a much better match to tuff than the deepslate ores – just a thought. Even if this is unintentional, I think it should stay.

This is the same in all cases. There is always a normal ore where tuff is generating. I think this was intended as it is also easier on the eyes and because it seems to be so consistent in the generation.

7 more comments

Please stop, this tracker is not for discussion. Mojang considers this a bug and that is that

Ok, I will let Mojang see this report and see me showing people the change log that says that this isn't a bug

Stop lucas, this is a bug and mojang see it as so, Henric will fix it

Well, adding Tuff versions would be like adding andesite, diorite and granite versions of them. I mean, they would be nice for building, but really maybe it would just be better to leave things simple.

(Personally I would like to have ores for all stones, maybe some exclusive to some stone in specific, but that should go to the feedback site. Anyway, I'll be happy if they add more variations, just to make the environment better.)

@unknown
MC-164101 had a Mojang Priority and an assignee, it was still marked as WAI

muzikbike

migrated

Confirmed

Important

World generation

block-missing-from-block-tag, block-tag-recommended

21w08a, 21w08b, 21w10a

21w11a

Retrieved