mojira.dev
MCPE-104226

When you break the top of a door in creative mode the item is dropped

If you break the top of a door is dropped. If you break the down of a door isn't dropped. This is not consistent and very annoying. In the videos it is very clear. This only happen in creative mode, in survival the breaking of the doors works as expected.

Related issues

BDS-10808 Iron Doors Drop BDS-11872 Doors drop tthemselves when break the top half in Creative mode. BDS-14617 Bedrock Bug , Door Duplicated In Creative Mode BDS-15531 Door glitch MCPE-104290 Breaking a top half of a door in creative mode still drops the door MCPE-105533 Door item drops when broken in creative mode MCPE-106553 Create Moda falls to the ground when the door is broken. MCPE-110213 Doors drop in creative mode after the new 1.16.200 update MCPE-110694 Doors drop their item in creative mode MCPE-111001 When you break the top half of a door in creative mode, it still drops. I have noticed this happening with villages this morning MCPE-111055 You can pick up iron doors in creative mode when destroyed MCPE-112156 Spruce doors will drop items when destroyed in creative. MCPE-112159 Doors drop as items in creative mode MCPE-112170 Breaking doors form the upperside give item MCPE-112342 Crimson doors drop when broken in creative MCPE-112702 doors are multiplied MCPE-113004 Door When Broken In Creative Mode From The Top Drop The Door Of That Item MCPE-113009 Break doors in creative drops them as items MCPE-113261 When I am in creative mode, I place an acacia door and then break it. When I break it, it drops the item of the door. This is classified as a bug because I am in creative and it is not supposed to drop anything. MCPE-113568 Creative mode door drop bug MCPE-114545 In creative mode, doors drop when destroyed MCPE-114764 Door dropped in Creative Mode MCPE-115152 door dupe MCPE-115445 Break the doors, dropped items MCPE-116359 Doors drop item when broken from above in Creative mode MCPE-117406 Doors give the item when broken on Creative mode MCPE-118952 Doors drop themselves when break the top half in Creative mode. MCPE-119518 Doors drop when broken in creative!! MCPE-120558 Doors drop tiles in creative when broken from the top MCPE-121090 Doors in creative mode MCPE-121406 Items and blocks drops things somtimes when you destroy stuff in creative MCPE-121869 doors in creative MCPE-123098 Warped door drops as an item in creative mode MCPE-123839 Doors drop even in creative mode MCPE-124735 Doors dropping items in creative mode MCPE-125741 Realm Glitch MCPE-125905 Some blocks drop when destroyed in creative mode MCPE-126020 Doors can drop MCPE-126505 Non blocks glitch MCPE-126506 Non blocks glitch MCPE-126507 Non blocks glitch MCPE-127169 Doors drop on creative when top half is broken MCPE-129020 Doors dropping in creative MCPE-129789 Door drops item when broken in Creative Mode. MCPE-132057 Doors dropping in creative MCPE-132160 When breaking the top half of any door in creative, it drops the item MCPE-134129 Iron doors drop in creative (if open and powered from the back) MCPE-134365 Warped and crimson door drop their items when broke in creative. MCPE-135131 Even though this has been resolved, you can still break the top block of a door in Creative and it drops MCPE-135773 If a Player Breaks Top Half of Door in Creative the Door Item Drops in 1.17 and Above MCPE-135844 In creative, breaking any type of door drops the door (random) MCPE-135995 Door Drop Bug MCPE-136549 When the door hits the top half of the creation mode, it will fall into item form. MCPE-136770 Doors MCPE-136812 Doors Drop In Creative Mode When Broken On The Top Part MCPE-137442 Door drop in creative MCPE-137501 Doors somtimes drop when you mine them in creative MCPE-138151 Doors duplicate (sometimes) when you break them in creative MCPE-139423 Breaking Doors From The Top Part Drop Even If You Are In Creative MCPE-139501 Doors dropping when breaker In Creative mode MCPE-140530 I was on console and broke the top part of a door in creative and it dropped the door. MCPE-141433 Breaking a door's top part makes it drop in creative mode MCPE-143875 When standing next to a door in creative, if you break it, it drops the door. (In Beta) MCPE-144766 Creative Mode Doors MCPE-145356 When you are in creative mode when you brake a door of any type it drops and you can pick it back up which is very annoying MCPE-145437 Broken doors in the creative drop to the ground MCPE-147370 THE DOOR DROPS ITSELF IN CREATIVE MCPE-148806 iron doors from strongholds and woodland mansions drop item when broken, though in creative mode MCPE-149494 Door drop item when break top half MCPE-150746 Breaking the top half of a door drops the door in Creative MCPE-151064 doors are dropped as an item in creative mode MCPE-151929 Iron Doors drop in creative mode MCPE-152116 Doors sometimes drop themselves in creative when broken MCPE-152242 Doors drops item when destroyed in creative MCPE-152716 Doors drop themselves but only when breaking the top half MCPE-153325 Door drops if you break the top half in creative mode MCPE-155492 When in creative mode, if you break a door with that corresponding door in your hand it will break and drop a door. MCPE-156804 Mangrove Door Drops In Creative Mode MCPE-157345 doors drop in creative mode when mined from upper part MCPE-157571 when the player is in creative mode, the mangrove door falls out in this way, the inventory is clogged MCPE-158523 Mangrove Door MCPE-158566 Breaking a door at the top makes it drop the item in creative mode MCPE-159336 Iron Door item drops when door is broken in creative MCPE-159615 if you break the doors from above, they will fall out in creative mode MCPE-159947 Doors drop when it's broken in creative mode MCPE-160289 Door is dropped in creative MCPE-161727 Door MCPE-162472 Doors drop in creative when hitting the upper half MCPE-162713 When a door is clicked on the top half of it, to break it in creative, it drops itself in item form, which should not happen. MCPE-163366 Doors creates duplicate after breaking them (Creative) MCPE-163385 Doors drop as item when mined in creative mode MCPE-163439 doors drop while in creative MCPE-164846 Doors drop in creative mode when top half is broken MCPE-165627 Door Duplication Glitch in Creative Mode. MCPE-166467 Doors drop item in creative mode MCPE-168043 Doors dropping item MCPE-170002 Doors drop its item if a creative mode player breaks it MCPE-171344 Breaking Doors From The Top Part Drop Even If You Are In Creative MCPE-173861 Doors being broken in creative dropping the item MCPE-174762 chest, and door MCPE-179792 Doors drop as item in creative mode when you break the top half of them MCPE-181858 copper door top half drops the item in creative MCPE-182685 Copper door dropped on creative mode MCPE-182952 Doors MCPE-183953 Doors still drop in creative mode MCPE-184324 Door drops when broken in creative mode. MCPE-184602 Copper doors console creative tile drop

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media]
kmb600

affects 1.17.30.20

migrated

This also affects the most recent update (1.16.200).

kmb600

affects 1.16.201

osfanbuff63

Can confirm on Android!

migrated

affects 1.16.210.56

migrated

Affects newest version

migrated

This was a very old bug in Java: MC-20

migrated

affects 1.16.220.52

migrated

Also occurs with leaves sometimes dropping a sapling.

GoldenHelmet

This is controlled by the Tile Drops setting, or /gamerule dotiledrops. If you turn it off or set to false, the door does not drop when you break the top. Relates to MCPE-91102.

migrated

so why the top and you can break iron door in survival

 and drop https://youtu.be/27CpI3ngkbs

 

GoldenHelmet

@rayane assid: I have made a new report for the iron door in survival because this report only covers creative mode. Please add your vote to MCPE-126620.

These bugs happen because the game has to treat the top and bottom of a door as separate blocks that are attached to each other. That means when one breaks the other breaks, just like a torch breaks if you break the block that it is placed on. My guess is that only door bottoms can drop as items. So when you break the bottom of a door the game decides whether to drop the item based on the mining rules of the door block. However, if you break the top then the game decides whether to drop the item for the attached bottom half based on rules for dropping attached blocks, which is just the dotiledrops gamerule unless a special exception is coded.

migrated

Probably relates to MCPE-14.

DeeFeeCee

Affects 1.18.1

Jonathan5733

Affects 1.18.30.21

migrated

Effects 1.19.51

FoxBuggy

its true and so annoying

Invisible826

Still an issue. 

migrated

This actually affects survival, even breaking with your bare fists (iron doors)

Invisible826

@unknown that issue is been tracked at MCPE-126620.

GreasyBat735419

This is being fixed!!!!

Scio Regis

(Unassigned)

426855

Confirmed

Multiple

1.20.0.20 Preview, 1.19.60.24 Preview, 1.19.50.21 Preview, 1.19.10.22 Preview, 1.18.30.26 Beta, ..., 1.20.80.22 Preview, 1.21.0.26 Preview, 1.21.0, 1.21.3 Hotfix (PS4), 1.21.2 Hotfix

1.21.10.23 Preview, 1.21.20

Retrieved