mojira.dev
REALMS-10191

Unable to see others' chat messages / signs and written books don't work

Note

This report is about Java Realms only. If you are experiencing the issue on Bedrock Realms, please see the following reports:

The bug

Since 28 April 2022, my friends and I are unable to see each other's chat messages on my realm.

We tried a couple things, like changing the world, reuploading the world, restoring the world to an older back up. But nothing worked. For now we created a team, and are using /teammsg to chat with each otter. Also, /msg still works, though /say and /me are not working.

We found it out when we were just playing, I joined the game, and said hello, but didn't get any response. But they also said hello, but it didn't come to each other's chat.

Similar reports indicate that this issue may also affect the visibility of sign text to other players.

Linked issues

MC-259276 Bottom 2 lines of writing on signs disappears on Java Realms. Resolved MC-259324 my friends can join my realm, but they can't type in chat. Resolved MC-259456 Writeable book and quill doesn't save when closed Resolved MC-260965 In-game Signs' Text Keeps Disappearing Resolved MC-274319 Book loses random pages and random text on Realms. Resolved

Attachments

Comments 45

I wanted to report it to realms bug tracker. I am sorry that I did it by the rong category. But if I am right I cant change that, or delete the bug report.

You may have accidentally muted them: press p to open the "communication" menu I think it's called?

No thats not it, if also checkt that. And al 3 of us have that problem on the realm wiht not seeing each others messages

 

[Mod] violine1101

Moved this to the REALMS project.

Can confirm. On my 1.18.2 realm I am encountering the same two issues:

1. chat messages from other players don't show (yes, I checked, they are not blocked in the communications screen)
2. signs are empty

More Info on 1):
Using /say will display the chat to everyone, using /me will not. Using /tell or /w will work, so will /tm and /teammsg.

For 2) I have some more information on how it looks on my end:

  • New signs that are placed manually in survival will show the text for a second before being cleared. Using /data get to look at the data reveals that the sign is actually empty, the written text has been removed.

  • Existing signs, while they appear just as empty as freshly placed ones, show their original text using /data get. They also show a new nbt data field called FilteredTextX where X is the line(s) that previously had text in them. This is not the case on new signs.

  • using /data merge to put text on a sign makes THAT text visible, but it won't show other text.

  • Existing signs with formatted text (placed through commands, in this case with colored, bold and clickable text) do not seem to be altered whatsoever and are also still displaying their text.

I'm happy to provide any additional details on either one if I can.

35 more comments

Apparently this is still happening in 1.21.1. After about a month of no chat issues at all in my Java realm, even with the profanity filter still on (didn't realize there was an option), random messages would not show up starting a few days ago. It would say "This message has been hidden for some players" or would ### out a specific word, even if it was a totally normal word. The censoring got worse over the past few days until tonight every single chat was blocked with that "hidden" message. This only persisted for about 20 minutes until they randomly started working again. Certain words are still banned though, even with the profanity filter turned off. I also had a book & quill page randomly erase itself multiple times early on in the realm but that appears to have fixed itself too because someone else wrote in it and the writing is still there. I guess a lot of people are having similar issues and not all of them have worked out well, so I'm hoping that my issues either stay resolved or someone is able to come up with a solution to this.

still having the same issue on 1.21.4 java realm 

Logan Zimmerman

happening on mine and my friends' 1.21.5 realm

Logan Zimmerman

It isn’t happening with all signs though, just with some characters and lines of text on some signs.

Logan Zimmerman

Specifically with the “▄” lower half block unicode symbol and character combos like “C9” and “P1”

[media]

TheGhostSven

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Java

Retrieved